Let me understand you; you take issue with him because he “attacks” your “liturgical deficiencies” and then you turn around and quote from the very Prayer Book his Church uses, a document that many consider to be one of the most beautiful works of theological prose, or any prose for that matter that has ever been written and on top of that you manifest considerable pride in the process. My, “let he who is without sin cast the first stone”.
But that prayer, although it’s in the BCP, was written by a Catholic — fellow named Newman. You have heard of him, surely.
Don’t get me wrong. If I think we have issues, it is not our liturgy with which I find fault, only our execution. We’re a relatively new parish, and I am becoming more and more impressed by the length of time and effort it takes to make good liturgy look seamless and effortless.