Replies

I went ahead and removed 8,9 and 19 which addressed other confessions so the caucus can be maintained. If you'd rather have it opened, let me know.

The material on a link counts. For instance, if the website from which an article is posted includes links to Jack Chick material, it will be pulled.

Likewise, on the News Forum, if the link includes pornographic material, it will be pulled.

As to consistency in the application of Religion Forum guidelines, please be advised that I was on vacation last week. The Admin Moderators on duty used their best judgment in handling the notoriously hot thread.

Moreover, we have a policy of "stare decisis" - so that moderators do not disturb actions previously taken by other moderators.

For the record, unless the title includes a direct affront the caucus will not be broken on my watch. It would take something like "Protestants are heretics [Catholic Caucus]" to fail the test.

The material on a link counts. For instance, if the website from which an article is posted includes links to Jack Chick material, it will be pulled.

Not to be confrontational, but this isn't quite clear.

Let's say hypothetically, a Catholic write writes something and in it he mentions Jack Chick hating Catholics and has an illustration of one of Chick's publications, would that be considered a link?

Hope you had a great vacation!

can I make a request - for those of us who dont normally participate in caucus threads, not understanding thier purpose, is there some initial description to be made in the first post or article body to detail what specifically is expected of the posters ?

my apologies for intruding earlier....are questions disallowed now, or is complete allegiance to the premise expected without asking why -

I simply asked for Bible documentation of Mary's immaculate conception

regards

rev911