I think it is a wonderful idea; however, the ACLU and the gay thugs will do their best to bury it in lawsuits.
The reason the secular state allows the Amish to operate is because the Amish live in austerity and do not proselytize. The Catholics, on the other hand, attract hatred like a lightning rod because Catholicism is a viable, healthy alternative to modern ills.
It is not bad for the youngsters. The conditions they will grow under, if the state allows it at all, will be conditions of normalcy, not insularity.
BUMP!