Replies

No, think about it:

If Catholicism ISN’T the only TRUE church, then:

Confession doesn’t matter,
Valid reception of the Eucharist doesn’t matter,
Submitting your marriage to the pre-Cana process doesn’t matter,
All those Catholic morals (no divorce, no birth control, no abortion, no masturbation, no pornography) don’t matter,
The holy orders don’t matter.

What the Holy Father said picks up a harsh demeanor as filtered through the press, but if anyone doesn’t believe the substance of what the Holy Father said, they have no reason not to join an “easier” or more entertaining church. Furthermore, while his statements may annoy the Gene Robison-style Episcopalians, the ECLA Lutherans, and the PCUSA Presbyterians, I’m quite sure that the orthodox Anglicans, the Orthodox (Eastern) Catholics, the Missouri and Wisconsin Synods of the Lutheran churches, and the PCA or OCP Presbyterians will respect the Catholic Church’s stand far more; they, too, understand, that if all denominations were equally valid, than their doctrines are also worthless in turn.

"What the Holy Father said picks up a harsh demeanor as filtered through the press, but if anyone doesn’t believe the substance of what the Holy Father said, they have no reason not to join an “easier” or more entertaining church. Furthermore, while his statements may annoy the Gene Robison-style Episcopalians, the ECLA Lutherans, and the PCUSA Presbyterians, I’m quite sure that the orthodox Anglicans, the Orthodox (Eastern) Catholics, the Missouri and Wisconsin Synods of the Lutheran churches, and the PCA or OCP Presbyterians will respect the Catholic Church’s stand far more; they, too, understand, that if all denominations were equally valid, than their doctrines are also worthless in turn." Is this an argument that needs to be engaged in? Are you certain of that, and if so, would one like to defend against the inevitable counter claims of "moral equivelancy" that would be soon to come, and would serve to do nothing but inflame passions that should be quite burned out by now.