[annalex]

I am surprised by this decision: I made a comment on the wording of a prayer during Catholic Mass and did not characterized Calvinism in any negative way. Where did I attack the Calvinist confession in my remarks? I clarified that the English translation of the prayer was, in my opinion, made to draw a brighter distinction with Calvinism, and I explained the Catholic doctrine of unlimited atonement as I understand it. That is all.

Are we allowed to mention another confession by name in caucus threads? Please clarify.

I will continue treating this thread as a caucus thread and will not participate in the off-topic discussions about Limited Atonement. Anyone wishing to make that a topic can easily start a thread for it. I would like to discuss the first two chapters of Cur Deus Homo in peace. Thank you.

[Religion Moderator]

If you would like to try again, let me know and I will lock this thread and you can create a new one with the very same article and a caucus designation.

Just be sure NOT to mention or suggest what another other confession believes (e.g. posts 23 and 29) because once you do, the other guy has an interest in responding.