Why do you insist that Israel have such a right? Exactly what harm comes to them if they don’t have this entry into the Vatican archives? Do they have the right to our state documents, so that Isarel can know for sure what our government did about the Holocaust during the war? I see the same attitude where the Democrats are demanding to know everything the administration did about the firing of the US DAs. It says: well, you are our enemy: proves that you are worthy of being our friend.
Of couse the Vatican would then be out of order to claim they proved anything concerning their actions concerning the Holocaust.
To say "we showed you all the documents (the documents we carefully collected for you to see) and they prove without question the whole story is known" seems a tad disenguous. No?
You can't have it both ways. What do you have to hide?