Interesting and heavy discussion...also an example of how academic careers are made, by causing a stir in the academic world. I think the first writer makes assumptions about Balthazar's state of mind, intentions and assumption that go beyond good taste and into mindreading.
He has been the person to shoot arrows at lately. Multiple academic careers will be made in the process.
I've been reading this discussion in "First Things" for several months. Very deep, and not likely to make much impact on my faith, I have to say.
However, I have to say that, although on the basic point, I generally agree with Ms. Pitstick, she's such a superior-toned grump that I really want to agree with the other guy!
Heads-up, Alyssa, if you're reading this ... your attitude is making enemies for your analysis.