[Running On Empty]

Nobody can answer such a question except God.

You are repeating the same misinformation about Catholic beliefs regarding salvation.

It gets tiresome.

[Iscool]

I asked: But tell us Protestants; at what point is the Catholic layperson filled with the Holy Spirit, and can/does God remove the Holy Spirit from some Catholics on ocassion???<.p>

You replied: Nobody can answer such a question except God.

You are repeating the same misinformation about Catholic beliefs regarding salvation.

It gets tiresome.

Well then, without posting a 40,000 word canned discourse, how does a Catholic gain salvation???

So, is the Catholic layperson, or not, filled with the Holy Spirit??? Or are you saying you can't know??? Are you saying only the Magisterium if filled with the Holy Spirit???

And what do you say to Protestants who 'know' they are filled with the Spirit of God???

Seems as tho Catholics like to shy away from this subject...