I disagree. If the guy were a PURE liar, he could've just made the story up from scratch. I think there's a grain of truth to his misleading story. What is it?
He reports that in every case, abortion was condemned. That suggests that he tested most priests on that issue. Why test only two priests on the issue of condoms with AIDS? Why those two? My bet is that the other 22 priests' answers had made the issue a non-starter: if a priest explicitly teaches that extramarital sex is wrong, why bother asking about condoms and AIDS?
you might be onto something.