[Religion Moderator]

As long as the "Catholic Caucus" threads do not speak of or for another confession in such a way that the other confession could object to a statement as false, incomplete, a strawman, etc. - there is no problem with the thread remaining closed.

In fact, I think it would be a great idea if each of the confessions were to begin a series to reveal their beliefs to the Lurkers: "Catholic beliefs on x [Catholic Caucus]".

As long as no other confession is mentioned, e.g. as a comparison, there is no reason the thread should opened for challenges or ridicule.

[Carolina]

How does one talk about one's conversion then from Protestantism to the Catholic Faith without any reference to doctrine? How does one say "After much study, I was convinced the X-doctrine is in error and so I came to believe as the Church teaches." Would that then be seen as a polemic attack?