Okay, one case in the seventeenth century, in America. Not something I'd really be nostalgic for. And at least de Sade left some thrilling literature behind. ;-D
It was clear from just a casual search that there were numerous executions for this offense, and that comports with my recollections from the history of the colonial period. From Blackstone forward this crime was held in complete abhorrence, and it was a capital offense until the general 19th century criminal reforms. Even the gay websites I ran across < shudder > agree with this, and seem to treat it as sort of like the Roman persecution of the Christians (iow, they glory in it.)