Pretty much. Have you seen any disagreement from the Protestants on the worth of this film? So far, I see only Rcs and EOs disliking it because it reveals Mary to have suffered pain in the normal, human birthing process which runs counter to your version that Mary somehow managed to give a bloodless birth to a child all the while remaining physically intact.
This thread has been instructive for several reasons, not the least of which is many Protestants have learned something they didn't know before about certain beliefs held by Rome.
ping
My version? I'm far more inclined to think your version, as you just stated, is more reasonable. I was merely making a comment that this thread, about whether the movie was suitable for Catholics and/or children has gone on for weeks and I wondered if that question had been decided. I can't tell, because none of what y'all are arguing about makes a lick of sense to me. :~)
to give a bloodless birth to a child all the while remaining physically intact. lol
Reminds me of that line in Julius Caesar where the seer says "He is not of woman born", implying Caesar's Godhood