[annalex]

we are called to caritas regardless of our creedal confession if we are truly Christian

To point out a heresy in a fellow Christian is charity. To defend the Church form attack is also charity.

[hosepipe]

[.. To point out a heresy in a fellow Christian is charity. To defend the Church from attack is also charity. ..]

Which church?..

[Quix]

To point out a heresy in a fellow Christian is charity. To defend the Church form attack is also charity.

= = =

For the above to be true—simply true; generally true . . .

particularly from God’s perspective would depend on a LOT of factors . . .

And biased, hide-bound, tradition bound, tidy-little box bound ... perspectives . . . have, in my experience and observations been chronically prone to wholesale error—i.e. virtually always very seriously wrong and wrong on more than a couple of scores, factors, issues.