Yeah, yeah but what about showing Mary in PAIN? Blasphemy.
Better tell Fr. Geiger to update his review. It's apparently beyond 'problematic'.
It's an artistic representation - a speculation about the reality of the moment. Does it constitute knowing and willful "hatred, reproach or defiance" of God?
From the stated intentions of the film makers, I find it difficult to reach that conclusion. An error? Perhaps. Blasphemy? It doesn't appear that way, if one can believe the stated intentions of the film makers.