Unfortunately, like many Catholics, abortion is not a priority for Jews when they are voting. I could be wrong, but I think that Jews have always been a pro-abortion demographic. Jews that I know are ravenously "pro-choice".
I know many Catholics that are into the "peace and justice" thing, which strangely adds up to a pro-abortion vote. Like their Jewish counterparts, I believe these people are more secular than they are religious.
Evangelicals seem to get it right,...or at least I have not heard otherwise.
A true Catholic is anti-abortion. Anything else, and they are not really adhering to the Catholic faith. Just like so many who call themselves a certain religion and then support "choice".
You are right.