What Does the Church Really Say about Music in Mass?

Catholic Exchange ^ | October 24, 2006 | Fr. James Farfaglia

[SuziQ]

IIRC, save the singers, NONE of the above is necessary for Gregorian Chant, nor polyphony.

Neither Gregorian Chant NOR polyphony are required to make a Mass valid. If a Parish likes guitar Masses, the participants at Mass are singing, praising God, receiving the Eucharist respectfully, why should that be an affront to anyone, or considered not valid? YOU or others may not like it, but there are usually several other Masses available at most Parishes on a weekend, so you don't have to attend a Mass with music that does not support your idea of worship.

I used to play Folk Masses all the time. I like some of the guitar Masses nowadays, but I prefer the more traditional music played on the organ and other classical instruments. That music doesn't make the Mass BETTER, just different. The music makes me more attuned to the meaning of the Mass, but it may be just the opposite for folks who prefer guitars and drums at Mass. They may find that they are more inclined to contemplate God and the awesome Gift he sent to us, when they're singing an upbeat hymn.

[Delta 21]

Oh! The drama !

[ninenot]

Just like STM, you should spend a number of years studying the writings of the Pontiffs on the topic.

Not the Weaklands, Bugninis, nor Pilarczyks.

In other words, seek the truth, not the "tongues which tickle your ears."

That's a word to the wise, if you can handle it.

[SuziQ]

Oh please! Don't even try to put me in the category you've created for those who do not share YOUR opinion of acceptable music in Mass. I've done my penance for singing "Blowing in the Wind" at Mass in the early 70's. Now I sing in the choir that is accompanied by the organ each Sunday, and at special holidays, the violin, cello, trumpets and tympanis. Talk about a joyful noise!!

There are many ways to express our love of the Lord, not just a single one that is acceptable. Pope Benedict has suggested a return to a more sacred canon for music in Mass, mainly because most of the music nowadays is just banal. From what I've read, he's not considering banning any particular type of music, he just wants those leading the music to be sure that it is doing what it should, leading us to a more complete relationship with the Lord, not just be there to entertain the crowd at Mass.