Of course not. They actually know what they are talking about, they don't throw around scurrilous accusations and they treat their pastors with respect.
They have every right to respectfully suggest ideas that would improve the liturgical life of the Church.
Okay. I would say that I am in agreement with the Reform of the Reform movement because they advocate a more organic liturgical reform unlike what came out of the Consilium.
Msgr. Gamber, who the current pope held in high esteem during his lifetime, said Paul VI made a mistake and that he erred in judgement when he promulgated the Novus Ordo in the form he gave it.
Reading Abp. Bugnini's "Reform of the Liturgy" turned my stomach because he explicitly said parts of the liturgy needed to be changed because they did not fit the "sensibility of the modern age." I am quoting from memory because it has been about 4 years since I checked it out of the George Mason University Library.
Okay. I would say that I am in agreement with the Reform of the Reform movement because they advocate a more organic liturgical reform unlike what came out of the Consilium.
Msgr. Gamber, who the current pope held in high esteem during his lifetime, said Paul VI made a mistake and that he erred in judgement when he promulgated the Novus Ordo in the form he gave it.
Reading Abp. Bugnini's "Reform of the Liturgy" turned my stomach because he explicitly said parts of the liturgy needed to be changed because they did not fit the "sensibility of the modern age." I am quoting from memory because it has been about 4 years since I checked it out of the George Mason University Library.