Darwin is a Problem for Jews

The Jerusalem Post ^ | 4/18/2006 | David Klinghoffer

[Zionist Conspirator]

Did the software in the cell, DNA, write itself? Is genetic information the only information that science has ever encountered that was not generated by an intelligent agent? These are some of the questions raised by the scientific and cultural war going on over Charles Darwin's theory and its modern challenger, intelligent design.

In an April 6 Jerusalem Post op-ed, the writer and editor Larry Yudelson took me to task for arguing in numerous venues that the debate about Darwin is a crucial one for Jews who care about Judaism. If it was simply Yudelson offering his personal opinion that "Darwin is no problem for Jews" (the title of his article), I wouldn't have sought the generous permission of the editor to respond.

But given that Yudelson also summons no less a figure than Maimonides to the defense of Darwin, along with another rabbinic luminary, Abraham Isaac Kook, a response is necessary. MAIMONIDES lived seven centuries before Darwin presented his argument that natural selection operating on random genetic variation produced you and me. Yet Judaism's greatest sage of the past millennium was engaged in a strikingly similar scientific argument in his own time.

That argument centered on the question of whether the universe is eternal and without a starting point (the position of Aristotle) or whether it had a beginning in time at the moment of creation (Maimonides's view).

Larry Yudelson recommends to us the path of Maimonides, "who opposed his contemporaries who preached the eternity of the world simply because 'the theory has not been proved' (Guide II:25), while allowing that were it to be proved, it would not contradict the core Jewish beliefs."

I wish Mr. Yudelson had read that important chapter in Guide for the Perplexed more carefully. In fact, the sage writes that he rejects the eternity of the world for two reasons not, as Yudelson says, just one.

First, Maimonides rejected Aristotle's thinking on this point because it "has not been demonstrated." But second because it makes nonsense of the Jewish religion: "If the philosophers would succeed in demonstrating eternity as Aristotle understands it, the Torah as a whole would become void, and a shift to other opinions would take place. I have thus explained to you that everything is bound up with this problem."

Maimonides was saying that though parts of the Bible's text may indeed be interpreted in other than a literal fashion, there are philosophical reasons that make an eternal universe incompatible with the God of the Torah. Simply put, Aristotle makes God's role in the world, as a creator and guide, superfluous and impossible. AND DARWINISM does the very same thing, ascribing all creation to blind material processes, as Darwin himself wrote: "I would give absolutely nothing for the theory of natural selection if it requires miraculous additions at any one stage of descent."

Maimonides would ask if Darwinism nevertheless has been "demonstrated." Well, Darwin's followers reached a high point of self-confidence in 1959 with the Centennial Celebration held at the University of Chicago to mark the 100th-year anniversary of the publication of The Origin of Species. The event was notable for the total conviction on the part of many speakers that any debate about Darwin was over and done.

But since then, the intellectual trend has changed directions. The Discovery Institute has compiled a list of Darwin-doubting scientists, a list currently standing at more than 500 doctoral researchers at places like Berkeley, Princeton and MIT.

It is now 71 years since Rav Kook died. So obviously in writing the beautiful and poetic words that Larry Yudelson quotes, Kook was not aware of the current state of knowledge about microbiology and the nanotechnology of the cell. Was Kook a close student of Darwin's writings or of the state of biology even in his own day? Is Yudelson?

In theory, it's very inspiring and idealistic to write, as Kook did, that: "In general this is an important principle in the conflict of ideas, that when an idea comes to negate some teaching in the Torah, we must not, to begin with, reject it, but build the edifice of the Torah above it, and thereby we ascend higher, and through this ascent, the ideas are clarified."

In practice, however, there is simply no way to reconcile an idea with its precise negation. The premise of Judaism is that God commands us on the basis of his having created us. The question before us, therefore, is not a simple-minded one of whether the universe was made in six calendar days, but rather of whether the universe has a need for a God, period.

In the philosophical system elaborated by Darwin and his disciples, there is no room for a creator in any sense. To explain the existence of life without reference to a deity was Darwin's entire purpose.

He developed a theory that answered his own purpose, certainly not ours as Jews. Given that his idea has neither been unambiguously demonstrated nor is it congenial to Jewish belief - the two-fold test of Maimonides - I am bewildered to find Jews who are committed to Judaism rushing recklessly to Darwin's defense.

[mlc9852]

But it's pretty clear God did create the heavens and the earth along with plants, animals and humans.

[Alter Kaker]

Out of curiosity, "Yehuda," how long did you serve in the IDF? How many children do you have currently in uniform? I see you criticizing Israelis a lot for supposed cowardice, and you even put their Jewishness in quotes, yet according to your profile you live in New York.

[Alter Kaker]

But it's pretty clear God did create the heavens and the earth along with plants, animals and humans.

I accept that, but where does it say how? It seems like you're reading an awful lot into a couple of sentence clauses in order to reject the bulk of modern science.

[Echo Talon]

I also believe what the Bible says. But I recognize that there are limits to what it says and does not say. One thing it doesn't explicate is the method God used to create the universe.

In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.
Genesis 1:1

Now if you are questioning the Lord maybe you should read this...

here

[mlc9852]

The only thing I reject is that humans came from ape-like creatures.

[PetroniusMaximus]

reference ping

[Alter Kaker]

In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.

Agreed. But it doesn't say how he did so. I see you like Job 40 -- but read Job 38, and God admonishes people like you who think you know more than you know.

[Alter Kaker]

The only thing I reject is that humans came from ape-like creatures.

That's fine, as long as you understand that your rejection of evolution is based on personal squeemishness and not on any sort of biblical mandate.

[PetroniusMaximus]

"If we who are Christians are to accept Jesus as the Son of God as being a literal truth, then it is impossible for Him to have been mistaken on this account"


Excellent summation.

[CarolinaGuitarman]

Why was my post 17 removed? I said that the poster needed more historical study and that Darwin did not have a *rebellious* personality. He didn't; he was quite reluctant to rock the boat on a great many things. Is there a problem with stating this? I am at a loss as to what the problem was with the post.

Thanks in advance.

[Alter Kaker]

I'm not a Christian and I'm hesitant to challenge you on Christian theology, but since when do Christians believe that every single word of Jesus' was literally true? I was under the impression he was famous for speaking in parables.

[Echo Talon]

God admonishes people like you who think you know more than you know.

All I know is whats in the Bible, I'm not questioning it.

[Religion Moderator]

The phrasing was contentious and personal therefore I removed it.

[PetroniusMaximus]

"I was under the impression he was famous for speaking in parables."

He did indeed. But in most cases it is made clear by the author that Jesus was using a parable.

Almost always, an introductory phrase such as, "Another parable put he forth unto them, saying, The kingdom of heaven is likened unto..." to distinguish a parable.

On the other hand, Jesus claimed to have been an eye witness - to have actually been present when Lucifer was cast out of heaven. This would be before the creation of man. This implies a lot about Jesus' knowlege of the facts of creation.

[Alter Kaker]

All I know is whats in the Bible, I'm not questioning it.

And that's exactly the problem -- because the only things you seem to know are what's in the Bible. Job thought he understood creation too from Genesis (or its pre-Mosaic precursor) and he was wrong. As are you. The Bible does not explain creation. It dicusses what happened, but not how it happened.

[CarolinaGuitarman]

"The phrasing was contentious and personal therefore I removed it."

It wasn't meant the way it came out, and will watch myself more closely in the future.

Thanks for the speedy reply. :)

[Echo Talon]

That's fine, as long as you understand that your rejection of evolution is based on personal squeemishness and not on any sort of biblical mandate.

Thats amazing that you can tell people how to worship and interpret the Bible are you some kind of prophet?

[PetroniusMaximus]

"It dicusses what happened, but not how it happened."

But it clearly addresses HOW LONG it took!

:)

[Echo Talon]

The Bible does not explain creation. It dicusses what happened, but not how it happened.

Like we would understand even if it did, eat any apples lately? sheesh, how long would that book be? LOL!

[Junior]

The Conspiracy That Cares

Corrupting the World's Youth Since 1859

---

April 18, 2006

The CrevoSci Archive

Since June 25, 1999

---

Keyword Searches

• CREATION
• CREATIONISM
• CREVO
• CREVOLIST
• DARWIN
• DARWINISM
• EVOLUTION
• EVOLUTIONISM
• INTELLIGENT DESIGN
• SCIENCE

---

Links

• List-O-Links

---

Box Scores
(All values subject to change)

Year	Threads	Daily Avg.
1999	42	0.12
2000	120	0.33
2001	256	0.70
2002	442	1.21
2003	542	1.48
2004	520	1.42
2005	1395	3.82
2006	548	5.12
Totals	3866	1.55

---

Lost Threads	%
44	1.14

---

Participants	Banned	%
1159	129	11.13

---

Freepdays for April

1. [04/05/2001] <1/1,000,000th%
   
2. [04/27/2001] A2J
   
3. [04/22/2003] AdmSmith
   
4. [04/26/1999] Amos the Prophet
   
5. [04/20/2000] anguish
   
6. [04/01/2005] BigFinn
   
7. [04/12/2005] bigmac0707
   
8. [04/28/2003] Blzbba
   
9. [04/27/2005] bobbdobbs
   
10. [04/03/1998] ckilmer
    
11. [04/10/1998] connectthedots
    
12. [04/03/2001] cryptical
    
13. [04/26/2005] david ford
    
14. [04/03/1998] D-fendr
    
15. [04/19/2001] Diddle E. Squat
    
16. [04/24/2001] Doe Eyes
    
17. [04/27/2001] dogbyte12
    
18. [04/23/1998] DouglasKC
    
19. [04/23/2000] elfman2
    
20. [04/07/1998] ex-snook
    
21. [04/21/2004] flevit
    
22. [04/15/2003] forty_years
    
23. [04/18/2004] GretchenM
    
24. [04/11/2001] handk
    
25. [04/06/2003] hiho hiho
    
26. [04/26/2001] JmyBryan
    
27. [04/13/2001] JohnnyM
    
28. [04/22/2003] JTN
    
29. [04/12/1999] JudyB1938
    
30. [04/02/2003] Kokojmudd
    
31. [04/13/2001] Liberal Classic
    
32. [04/09/1999] LiteKeeper
    
33. [04/23/2000] Mamzelle
    
34. [04/14/2002] mhking
    
35. [04/14/2004] newsgatherer
    
36. [04/06/2001] Non-Sequitur
    
37. [04/01/2003] nosofar
    
38. [04/29/1999] OBAFGKM
    
39. [04/25/1999] ovrtaxt
    
40. [04/02/2006] Paddlefish
    
41. [04/26/2000] pageonetoo
    
42. [04/12/2001] Paleo Conservative
    
43. [04/24/2003] Paloma_55
    
44. [04/26/2001] RadioAstronomer
    
45. [04/09/2000] sarcasm
    
46. [04/25/1998] sirchtruth
    
47. [04/11/2003] Sola Veritas
    
48. [04/04/2005] USFRIENDINVICTORIA
    
49. [04/02/1998] Wallace T.
    
50. [04/08/2002] whattajoke
    
51. [04/24/2005] Wrangler22
    
52. [04/23/1999] zbogwan2
    
53. [04/21/2004] Zhangliqun
    

CrevoSci Threads for the Past Week

1. 04/18/2006 Darwin is a Problem for Jews [Religion]
2. 04/18/2006 We believe in ET, not ID [Darwin, SETI, & ID in one thread!]
3. 04/17/2006 Environmentalism and the apocalypse
4. 04/17/2006 Schizophrenia as Misstep by Giant Gene [Chat]
5. 04/16/2006 Media Overblows Claims of 'Human Evolution': Examining the Newest 'Missing Link'
6. 04/16/2006 Science does not challenge my faith - it strengthens it [Bishop of Oxford]
7. 04/15/2006 Rebutting Darwinists: (Survey shows 2/3 of Scientists Believe in God)
8. 04/15/2006 The end of humanism: Mankind doesn’t fare too well in cutting-edge intellectual thinking
9. 04/13/2006 Creature's picture irks Board of Ed member (FSM alert)
10. 04/13/2006 Evolution follows few of the possible paths to antibiotic resistance
11. 04/13/2006 Fossil Find Is Missing Link in Human Evolution, Scientists Say
12. 04/13/2006 Inheritance Is More Than Gene Deep
13. 04/13/2006 Royal Society statement on evolution, creationism and intelligent design
14. 04/13/2006 Singularity Summit At Stanford Explores Future Of 'Superintelligence'
15. 04/12/2006 A Darwinian View of Immigration
16. 04/12/2006 Addressing Religious Beliefs (Intelligent Design) In Class [Smoky Back Room]
17. 04/12/2006 Ancient fossils fill gap in early human evolution [Chat]
18. 04/12/2006 Both antievolution bills in Maryland dead
19. 04/12/2006 Darwin Was Not Influenced by Science [Religion]
20. 04/12/2006 Fossil connects human evolution dots [Chat]
21. 04/12/2006 Scaring for money
22. 04/12/2006 Seeking Ancestry in DNA Ties Uncovered by Tests
23. 04/11/2006 Christianity: child abuse? A virus? (Evolutionist Dawkins thinks Christianity is child abuse) [Bloggers]
24. 04/11/2006 Debris Disks Show Solar System Design [Religion]
25. 04/11/2006 Female red-back availability determines male's size: study
26. 04/11/2006 Intelligent design goes Ivy League: Cornell offers course despite president denouncing theory
27. 04/11/2006 Rio Rancho school board approves new policy concerning evolution, Big Bang
28. 04/11/2006 Scopes: The Battle Over America's Soul (Upcoming tomorrow on History Channel) [Chat]
29. 04/11/2006 Time to Give It Up [Intelligent Design and Irreducible Complexity]

This week in CrevoSci History

1. 04/18/2005 Can creationists be scientists? [Bloggers]
2. 04/18/2005 Fossil turtles confound evolutionists (Creation vs. Evolution)
3. 04/16/2005 Preshistoric Jawbone Reveals Evolution Repeating Itself
4. 04/15/2005 Intellectual honesty devolves (Anti-Bush, Anti-Religion, WPost Barf Alert!)
5. 04/15/2005 Reproductive riddle unscrambled [Fossilized eggs found inside dinosaur supports a link with birds]
6. 04/14/2005 'Andrew McIntosh, Mathematics' (Creation vs. Evolution...there has to be a Designer) [Chat]
7. 04/13/2005 Salamanders are 'living fossils'? (Creation vs. Evolution) [Bloggers]
8. 04/13/2005 Scientists Analyze Chromosomes 2 and 4: Discover Largest 'Gene Deserts'
9. 04/13/2005 The Big Lab Experiment Was our universe created by design?
10. 04/13/2005 Upper Paleolithic blues: Consequences of recent dating fiasco on human evolutionary prehistory [Bloggers]
11. 04/12/2005 Archaeoraptor hoax update: National Geographic recants [Bloggers]
12. 04/12/2005 Can creationist be scientists? [Bloggers]
13. 04/12/2005 Sacred constant might be changing
14. 04/12/2005 The Geologic Column: Does It Exist? (Creation vs. Evolution) [Chat]
15. 04/12/2005 Truth is a monkey on pols' backs (Richard Cohen: 'Half Of America Rejects Theory Of Evolution.'
16. 04/11/2005 The Science of Design
17. 04/10/2005 Mammoth, Tusks Found by Los Angeles-Area Builders
18. 04/10/2005 Scientists shun Kansas evolution hearing
19. 04/18/2004 Dancing Girls And The Merry Magdalenian (13,000 Y.O. Painting, UK)
20. 04/17/2004 Distorting science for the secular agenda
21. 04/17/2004 IRS raids business, home of creationist (Dr. Dino)
22. 04/16/2004 Evolution: Like a Waterfall That Flows Upward! [Bloggers]
23. 04/16/2004 Oldest Jewelry? 'Beads' Discovered in African Cave
24. 04/15/2004 Evolution’s Mirror in a Fish’s Spines [Micro vs. Macro Evolution]
25. 04/15/2004 Old Stones Reveal Their Age (New Dating Method: Quartz Hydration)
26. 04/14/2004 How likely is human extinction?
27. 04/14/2004 Old Mound My Lead To New Ideas About People 5,000 Years Ago (Mexico)
28. 04/14/2004 Study Finds Sex Differences in Chimpanzee Learning
29. 04/13/2004 Archaeologist Talks About Oregon's Early Natives
30. 04/13/2004 Humans Took 1000 Years To Tame Wild Plants
31. 04/13/2004 Italian Skeletons Reveal Old World Diseases
32. 04/13/2004 Who really discovered America? (Evidence that the Jews did!)
33. 04/12/2004 CNN Accused of Fabricating Controversy in Missouri Evolution Story
34. 04/12/2004 Ethiopia to Exhibit 'Lucy' Fossil in United States
35. 04/11/2004 Split Between English and Scots Older Than Thought
36. 04/10/2004 Scientific integrity and the gospel of Christ
37. 04/16/2003 Latest Creationist Effort, E for effort... but totally lame (Warning: Large Image) [Religion]
38. 04/14/2003 Study of the Cosmos Proceeds, But Will Take New Directions
39. 04/11/2003 Mass-extinction controversy flares again (Chicxulub crater kills dinosaurs, or not?)
40. 04/11/2003 Scientist Defends Account Of Exodus
41. 04/10/2003 NASA Researchers Put New Spin On Einstein's Relativity Theory
42. 04/18/2002 Primate ancestor lived with dinos
43. 04/17/2002 Details Revealed About Huge Dinosaurs
44. 04/17/2002 MUTATED MUMMICHOGS: Scientist Studies Tiny Fishes' Adaptation to Pollution
45. 04/17/2002 Scientists Discover New Insects
46. 04/17/2002 Scientists push back primate origins
47. 04/16/2002 A Blast From The Sun
48. 04/16/2002 Is This The Real Noah's Ark, Found At Last? The Mystery Of The 'Ararat Anomaly'
49. 04/15/2002 'Anti-freeze' chemical found in Milky Way
50. 04/15/2002 Medieval Black Death Was Probably Not Bubonic Plague
51. 04/15/2002 Super Ant Colony Found in Europe
52. 04/15/2002 Super Ant Colony Found in Europe [Chat]
53. 04/14/2002 'Intelligent Design Creationism and Its Critics': Supernatural Selection
54. 04/13/2002 To Creationists: Is There a Global Conspiracy to Promote Evolution? [Pulled]
55. 04/12/2002 And then there was... postmodernism (leftists pushing an anti-evolution agenda) [Religion]
56. 04/12/2002 Radar Reveals Five Double Asteroid Systems Orbiting Each Other Near Earth [Chat]
57. 04/12/2002 Scientists Say Asteroids' Bigger Belt Is Nothing To Worry About [Chat]
58. 04/11/2002 A great leap backwards
59. 04/11/2002 Most distant galaxy cluster found [Chat]
60. 04/11/2002 Researchers Uncover Brain Patterns That Differentiate Humans From Chimpanzees
61. 04/11/2002 Scientists sort the chimps from the men
62. 04/10/2002 (Creationists) CRSC Correction [Pulled]
63. 04/10/2002 Bush: 'Life Is A Creation, Not A Commodity'
64. 04/10/2002 Weird Stars Show Evidence of New Form of Matter
65. 04/17/2001 Redheads 'are neanderthal'
66. 04/11/2001 Computers that Improve Themselves
67. 04/10/2001 Before the Big Bang
68. 04/10/2001 Do You Believe in Evolution?
69. 04/10/2001 Virus in DNA 'is cause of mental illness'
70. 04/18/2000 SCIENCE & CREATIONISM: Frequently Asked Questions
71. 04/11/2000 The Magic of Evolutionary Speciation, Part III

The Wall
"In death, all men are equal"

1. 1LongTimeLurker
2. 2Trievers
3. Ada Coddington
4. Ahab Brigade
5. Ahriman
6. akdonn
7. Alas
8. ALS
9. Always Learning
10. angelo
11. anthraciterabbit
12. Area Freeper
13. Aric2000
14. Askel5
15. AskStPhilomena
16. Asphalt
17. biblewonk
18. bluepistolero
19. Boot Hill
20. broberts
21. churchillbuff
22. claptrap
23. Clinton's a liar
24. codebreaker
25. Con X-Poser
26. D. Skippy
27. david ford
28. dbbeebs
29. Destro
30. DittoJed2
31. dob
32. drstevej
33. Ed Current
34. emiller
35. Exnihilo
36. f.Christian
37. Far Gone
38. farmfriend
39. followerofchrist
40. freeparella
41. general_re
42. geros
43. Good Tidings Of Great Joy
44. goodseedhomeschool
45. gopwinsin04
46. gore3000
47. H.R. Gross
48. Halfmanhalfamazing
49. Happy2BMe
50. Helms
51. Ignatius J Reilly
52. IllumiNOTi
53. ironwoodchuck
54. jec1ny
55. JediGirl
56. JesseShurun
57. JethroHathaway
58. JFK_Lib
59. jlogajan
60. JoeSchem
61. John H K
62. john_baldacci_is_a_commie
63. Justice Avenger
64. Kerberos
65. Kevin Curry
66. kharaku
67. knowquest
68. Land of the Irish
69. LarryLied
70. Le-Roy
71. malakhi
72. Marathon
73. masked face doom
74. medved
75. Merdoug
76. metacognative
77. MikalM
78. mikeharris65
79. missyme
80. Modernman
81. Morris Hattrick
82. mrustow
83. n4sir
84. neoconsareright
85. newsgatherer
86. newsperson999
87. NoKinToMonkeys
88. nuda_veritas
89. Ogmios
90. OnlyinAmerica
91. peg the prophet
92. Pern
93. Phaedrus
94. Phoroneus
95. pickemuphere
96. RCW2001
97. ReasonedThought
98. ret_medic
99. rhtwngwarrior
100. RickyJ
101. RJCogburn
102. Sabertooth
103. ScotchBible
104. SeaLion
105. Selkie
106. Shubi
107. spazzedgadfly
108. spiker
109. SplashDog
110. Stingy Dog
111. StupidQuestions
112. That Subliminal Kid
113. The Loan Arranger
114. the lone rider
115. Tomax
116. tpaine
117. Truth666
118. Turan
119. twittle
120. Unalienable
121. USA2000
122. vincentblackshadow
123. vincenteblackshadow
124. WaveThatFlag
125. What about Bob?
126. Willie Green
127. winner45
128. xm177e2
129. zide56

---