It is difficult to argue with Traditionalists because their arguments are inconsistent and illogical. Moreover, they disagree among themselves on many issues, including the validity of the 1962 missal, whether the see of Rome is vacant, etc. ad nauseum. If only it were possible to learn what the position of the traditionalists actually is.
"It is difficult to argue with Traditionalists because their arguments are inconsistent and illogical."
Ok, I'll bite; give me ONE argument inconsistant/illogical.
Really, I find that true about the neo-Caths, do they believe in birth control or not? Do they believe in the real presence or not? Is it okay for nuns to do homilies or not? Are clown Masses acceptable liturgy or not? If only it were possible to learn what the position of the neo-Catholics actually is.