Replies

Again, it is specific to him giving care of his mother to a non-relative. He would not have done that.

based on what Scripture?

We know from the Bible that Mary and Joseph had sex, that Jesus was the firstborn, meaning others were born after, and we know that he had siblings from the bible.

So where in the Bible is it a sin for Jesus to give care of Mary to John?

"We know from the Bible that Mary and Joseph had sex"

Nope. Full Court, it has been pointed out to you a dozen times that you do not know this. The Bible never says this. The Bible says that Mary did not have sexual relations with Jospeh, prior to the birth of the Christ. It does not say that she that Joeseph had sexual relations with the Mother of the Christ after His birth. You feel it is implied by the word "until." Not an unreasonable interpretation, but not a definitive one either. The BIBLE nowhere says that Joseph had sexual relations with the Mother of the Lord. That is your own personal opinion. You are entitled to it, but it is an opinion and not a fact.

" that Jesus was the firstborn, meaning others were born after,"

Nope. You can be both the first born and the last born. The terms do not exclude each other.

" and we know that he had siblings from the bible."

The question is whether Mary had children, not whether Jesus had siblings. Name the Children of Mary, from the Scriptures.

We know from the Bible that Mary and Joseph had sex, that Jesus was the firstborn, meaning others were born after, and we know that he had siblings from the bible.

This is so pathetically ill-informed there is no point continuing any type of conversation. Full Court, God bless you for your vigor, but please gain some knowledge before attempting to have a serious discussion again.