[HarleyD]

Is there even one Catholic stating anywhere on this thread that Scripture is not inspired? Can you cite that argument being made?

The argument isn't about scripture not being "inspired". The argument is elevating tradition over scripture. Please note the above post and I believe there is a whole thread dedicated to this cause.

Which door would you pick?

1) If you read white in the scripture and the Church says its black, then it's black. (Ignatius)

2) You read different passages and reason it out. (Augustine)

Giving false witness is still a sin.

Thanks for the reminder. I'll put that one right under "#45 Praying to carved images".

[SoothingDave]

"HarleyD" post 172: It is astonishing to me to listen to these Catholics argue AGAINST the divine inspiration of the holy scriptures

Did you catch the guy who logged on to your computer as you and posted the above?

The argument isn't about scripture not being "inspired". The argument is elevating tradition over scripture. Please note the above post and I believe there is a whole thread dedicated to this cause.

So you make a wild claim that Catholics are arguing against the divine inspiration of Scripture, then when questioned to provide any evidence of a Catholic making that claim, you claim this isn't what the argument is about.

Well, then what gives with the slurs and slander?

SD