As one of the Orthodox participants, I'm a little disappointed that you still think that there are only two "sides" in this grand debate! If a few "free-will" Protestants (who are probably in the vast majority world-wide) would show up, we'd have even more sides!
I would be somewhere in the middle. I am not a protestant and not a Catholic.
Truth be told, when you boil it down, since most proddy's still believe in infant baptism, I don't see as how the daughter feel too far from the mother tree. :-)
I debated on how to phrase it and I thought it would be NICER to say it the way I did. :) I surmised that if you added up all the relevant posts, they would break 10 to 1 in highlighting the unity between Orthodox and Catholics, rather than the differences. But I know there are several differences, and I have enjoyed learning about them.
I, for one, am very surprised that there have not been more "free-will" Protestants chiming in. That would make it more of a "Cage Match!" :)