[annalex]

The alternative is to say that only some bear the sin of Adam as opposed to others.

This is exacly what is being argued for Blessed Mary and John the Baptist, as well as Christ himself. Do not forget the children and the insane either.

[Forest Keeper]

FK: "The alternative [to reading in Rom. 3 that "all" really means "all"] is to say that only some bear the sin of Adam as opposed to others."

This is exactly what is being argued for Blessed Mary and John the Baptist, as well as Christ himself. Do not forget the children and the insane either.

I don't think those with diminished capacity (by age or condition) are exempt from the nature of their birth, but I do think they may not be held accountable for their nature in the same way we are.

Do Catholics believe that John the Baptist was sinless?