No, you've both gone much further than that.
You're not saying that a Pope can be in error.
You're both saying that he most definitely is in error. Without any question. You called it "a reality."
You're saying that he's wrong and you're right.
His own Canon law says it, as well as many canon lawyers (who told him so).
Listen marshmallow, Archbishop Lefebvre, and the bishops he consecrated were a few of the remaining churchmen that actually believe EENS and that hell is real. Do you really think that they would, (which the charge claims they did) do something with the intent of separating themselves from the Church? It's just absurd.