Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article

To: F16Fighter
Protestants in general abide in the simplicity of Christ's message and belief in the redemption of the soul through His blood sacrifice

Nope, you just confirmed my point. "Message" and "belief" are doctrinal references.

Catholicism is steeped in a litany doctrines that not even Catholics are sure they understand.

That's how Protestants view it from the outside, but that's not how Catholics experience it. The kernel of a Protestant service is a sermon expounding on the Scriptures. The kernel of a Catholic Mass is the prayer of the priest and people to the Father through Jesus Christ to consecrate the Eucharist. The sermon is an afterthought (optional except on Sundays and high holy days!), and any doctrinal content to the liturgy (and it's possible there isn't nearly enough) is ... well ... not an afterthought, but certainly not central.

It's funny that you say "not even Catholics are sure they understand". It's a very Protestant thing to say. All human doctrines are a created intellect's attempt to understand an infinite God. From my Catholic perspective, if you -- as a created intellect -- are "sure" you "understand" just about any Christian doctrine ... you almost certainly have it wrong.

And the Orthodox say that that's not nearly going far enough.

49 posted on 06/09/2005 3:41:49 PM PDT by Campion (Truth is not determined by a majority vote -- Pope Benedict XVI)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 48 | View Replies ]


To: Campion

"The kernel of a Catholic Mass is the prayer of the priest and people to the Father through Jesus Christ to consecrate the Eucharist."

Good point. The climax of Catholic Worship is when the priest, in the person of Christ, lifts up the consecrated Body and Blood and offers it to the Father, where we, the community, join our own sacrifices to the Father...

"THROUGH HIM (Christ), IN HIM, WITH HIM, IN UNITY WITH THE HOLY SPIRIT, ALL GLORY AND HONOR IS YOURS ALMIGHTY FATHER, FOREVER AND EVER"

Protestant worship is all about the preacher expounding on Scripture. Certainly a truncated form of praise - as it seems the focus is more on the preacher than on God Himself.

Regards


56 posted on 06/09/2005 4:15:39 PM PDT by jo kus
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 49 | View Replies ]

To: Campion
"The kernel of a Protestant service is a sermon expounding on the Scriptures."

True. But that kernel in it's simplicity is exactly what Christ Himself taught.

" The kernel of a Catholic Mass is the prayer of the priest and people to the Father through Jesus Christ to consecrate the Eucharist. The sermon is an afterthought (optional except on Sundays and high holy days!), and any doctrinal content to the liturgy (and it's possible there isn't nearly enough) is ... well ... not an afterthought, but certainly not central.

True again.

"It's funny that you say 'not even Catholics are sure they understand'. It's a very Protestant thing to say."

No, it's an observational "thing to say," one many Catholics I know will admit to. Btw, as well as a former Catholic, I'm not exactly wingin' it.

"All human doctrines are a created intellect's attempt to understand an infinite God.

They may begin that way, but eventually (as in the RCC -- facilitated most dramatically through Constantine -- embellish and recreate through the assumptive spectrum of man.

"From my Catholic perspective, if you -- as a created intellect -- are 'sure' you 'understand' just about any Christian doctrine ... you almost certainly have it wrong."

The only "Christian doctrine" is indeed Scripture.

57 posted on 06/09/2005 4:29:17 PM PDT by F16Fighter
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 49 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson