Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article

To: AnthonyCekada; gbcdoj; sinkspur

"Having a hole poked in you, a tube shoved in and then having to eat and drink that way would be burdensome for any normal man."

Burdensome schmurdensome!!! If that were the case then one could argue that the millions of people who use colostomy bags have a license to commit suicide as well, on the basis that they have to put up with holes being poked in them and tubes "shoved in".

Provision of nutrition and hydration, whatever the means, cannot be considered "extraordinary measures". These are basic requirements for life.

I fully agree with the comments made by sinkspur and gbcdoj on this one. If your approach to moral questions is reduced to "can I get away with this without committing a mortal sin?", then sinkspur is quite right - it is casuistry, and it stinks.

Even to ask the question "Is this 'mortally' sinful?" is an admission that the proposed course of action is wrong. To set out with the deliberate intent to commit a sin, particularly where the loss of a human life is the result of that sin, can itself be a mortal sin irrespective of the gravity of the specific action which is proposed.

If any Catholic, or other Christian for that matter, is serious about serving God, they do not ask "How far can I sin without losing my soul?", they ask "How can I do what is right and best and true?".



15 posted on 05/05/2005 5:07:03 PM PDT by Tantumergo
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies ]


To: Tantumergo; AnthonyCekada; gbcdoj; sinkspur
Well if a hole poked in you is an unreasonable burden, there goes all drugs administered via needle and syringe. I know I know "that's different". You can forget lab tests and any number of medical procedures. It has been stated before feeding tube are not extraordinary in todays medicine most are tubing tubes are for the convenience of the nursing staff. I have noticed the lack of Medical knowledge has not made a dent in the opinions of those who wish to pontificate on Mrs Shiavo. Like many Father Cekada has no clue what he is talking bout. Like many I suspect the conclusion was arrived at before the justifications were considered. I doubt more consideration will achieve much.

Who can hear the "Shepherd" with so much howling going on. What's a lamb to do?
54 posted on 05/06/2005 9:20:07 AM PDT by Mark in the Old South (Sister Lucia of Fatima pray for us)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 15 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson