You are correct that my recollection was wrong on some minor points. Nevertheless, the substance of my point was valid.
Good night.
PS: You never answered whether St. Alphonsus Liguori's quote, "Thus also Concina and Antoine say that it is not licit to seek the Sacraments from a heretic and/or schismatic, except in the case of extreme and/or the most grave necessity", supports heretics and schismatics. Doesn't your argument lead to that conclusion?
I teach catechism to high school students.
They know that even a pagan can baptize a child as a Catholic if the right intent, form and matter are used.
Maybe I'll give them your screen name for your further edification.