The problem with Catholics of his ilk is they seem to short circuit their logic process(and by the same token, ones like Ultima Radio have the same lapses of logic). To be, too many faithful Catholics are blindly obidient, no matter what, despite the fact the clergy may be anything but obidient, yet they defer to Judas like clergy and Bishops. To me, as Rod Dreher has mentioned on Amy Welborns blogs comment boxes, its one thing to be signle to try to keep the faith, but when ones family is involved the stakes become far higher. Should we defer to "obidience" to hetrodx clergy and bishops and watch their faith wither away? The same excapt thing took place in Holland and look at the results there.