[madprof98]

I’m NOT leaving and I’m NOT going to be quiet.

Then you need to be FIRED. Under JPII, people like this just went their merry "I'm a practicing Catholic but" way. Under Benedict XVI, they may be in for a surprise.

[Arguss]

Under JPII, people like this just went their merry "I'm a practicing Catholic but" way.

Does that mean she used to be "in communion" with the Church, but now she's not?

Is there potentially a new schism, and roles have been reversed?