Posted on 02/04/2005 6:19:27 AM PST by NYer
>>Is it bringing people closer to Christ, or is it creating a spectacle unto itself?<<
That is the question.
We in the church are not required to believe in any apparition or miracle even if it is ruled to be supernatural.
When that miracle becomes a cult unto itself and money is made hand over fist for the promoters of it, I feel it is evil. When one is drawn closer to Our Lord by the realization of it, that is good.
Amen. God bless.
Yeah -- the "under-world."
Satan is "supernatural" as well as God.
Satan is indeed quite capable of mimicking and invoking God's "creations" -- even impersonating Jesus Christ Himself.
>> Satan is indeed quite capable of mimicking and invoking God's "creations" -- even impersonating Jesus Christ Himself.<<
I agree with this but by it's fruits you can see if it is evil or good.
Do those that present the "miracle" profit from it?
Do those who promote it ask for fame or profit?
Does it make one think more of Our Lord or tell pilgrims to stray from the basic teachings of Jesus?
It is alright to look at something as a miracle as long as one does not worship the object or apparition.
When I hear someone who presented a miracle chooses a life walking in the steps of Our Lord, I have to look at it as something good.
The link is in post #8, read all about it! It's amazing.
Thanks!
Wow!
One would think that if this was just human flesh it would have deteriorated!
I agree, it is best to proceed with extreme caution. Sometimes people can become miracle and apparition chasers, and lose sight of what we know to be true.
I heard Fr. Groeschel say once, "You want to hear God speak to you? READ THE BIBLE. You want to see a miracle? GO TO MASS!" :-D
Therein lies the problem.
Too often the mere apparition automatically represents "good" without discernment.
"When I hear someone who presented a miracle chooses a life walking in the steps of Our Lord, I have to look at it as something good."
That in itself could be considered a "miracle" as well. Amen to that.
I have a close friend of mine who witnessed along with others a portrait of the Modonna "speaking" to them -- that is her lips actually moved.
Satan OR "miracle"?
P.S. -- This was at the home of someone who'd had had a much-publicized Marian Shrine in his yard, and of whom been "speaking to Our Lady."
Some of her "messages" did NOT turn out to be true.
>>P.S. -- This was at the home of someone who'd had had a much-publicized Marian Shrine in his yard, and of whom been "speaking to Our Lady."
Some of her "messages" did NOT turn out to be true.<<
Oooo, that's part of the problem. I think that the Devil himself has seen how devoted people can be after witnessing a true miracle. There are hundreds of people who are talking to or hearing from "Mary". I believe this is to confuse us.
Here is a list of Modern false Apparitions..
AMERICA'S FALSE APPARITIONS
Necedah, WIS,
Bayside, NY,
Charismatics,
Portavoz of MX,
St. Joseheph's Hill of Hope, Los Angeles, CA,
The Army of Mary, Canada
The Last Call of Canada
Maria Esperanza of Betania (although Betania is true),
Sr. M. Neuzil of Dayton, OH,
Fr. Albert Hebert of Paulina, LA,
Eileen George of Worcester, MA,
Miguel Poblete of Penablance, OH,
Maureen Sweeney of Cleveland, OH,
Vange Gonzales of Santa Fe, NM,
Nancy Fowler of Conyers, GA,
Elba & Zendia of Terra Blance, MX,
Bro. David of El Ranchilo, TX,
Estella Ruiz of Phoenix, AZ,
Mary Constancio of Lubbock, TX,
Pachi Borrero of El Cajas, EQ,
Father Spaulding of Scottsdale, AZ,
Gianna Sullivan and the rest of Scottsdale, AZ,
Marvin Kucera of Scottsdale, AZ,
Theresa Lopez of CO,
Januszkiewicz of Marlboro, NJ,
Singer of Burlinton, ON,
Reinhiltz of Hillside, IL,
Carol Nole of Santa Maria, CA,
Fr Bruse of Lake Ridge, VA,
Veronica Garcia of Denver, CO,
Tony Fernwalt of Steubenville, OH,
Ray doiron of Belleville, IL,
Rosa Lopez of Hollywood, FL.
False Apparitions in the Rest of the World
Problematic: 'Lady of All Nations' (1945 - Present)
Poem of the Man-God,
Luisa Piccarreta,
The Pebble of AUS,
Vassula Ryden of SZ,
Magnificat Meal Movement
Father Gino, of San Vittorino, Italy
Caterine Richero of France,
Lasut, Slovakia
Garabandal,
Ivetka and Katka Greek Catholic girls from the village of Litmanova. These apparitions are still not decided.
Rosa of Dan Damiano,
Gilli of Italy,
Alocci of Sant Stefano, Italy,
Carabelli of San Damiano, Italy,
Josyp Terelya of Ukraine,
Fr. Gobbi of Milan, Italy,
Julka of Yugoslavia,
Cuevas of El Escorial,
Rwanda (Very, very strange "approval" circumstances. We feel certain this is NOT of God.)
Medjugorje,
These apparitions are still not decided by the Vatican because the "apparitions" have not ended. Disapproved by the local Bishop and almost all Bishops of the former Yugoslavia (personally, when the Devil appeared in Our Lady's clothes, it creeped me out)
Aloisia Lex of Austria,
Julia Kim of Korea,
Oliveto Citra, Italy,
Ursula and Breda of Melleray, Ireland,
Paul of Blue Mt., AUS,
Cameroon, AF,
Rosemary O'Sullivan of IRE.
Maria Kizyn of Ukraine,
Sr. Anna Ali of Rome,
Christina Gallagher of IRE,
Zenovai of Ukraine,
Singer of Ontario,
Ivetka and Katka of Slovakia,
Matthew Kelly of AUS,
Rossi of Rome.
The person I referred to IS on your list.
Btw, Our Lady of Medjugorie is also false.
>>Btw, Our Lady of Medjugorie is also false.<<
I believe it is as well.
The handlers of those "seers" know how to work it well. They will not have the appparitions stop eventhough the "Gospa" has stated more than once that they will.
The Vatican will not rule on it until the apparitions stop. The Holy See has stated that no group can go there with the intention of venerating the site. The tours still go on. I went to church today and a group of ladies had a flyer about a tour. I didn't know what to say except that it is not approved. They didn't seem to mind.
The local Bishop has said many times that nothing supernatural is happening there. He is wrong only in the fact that there is nothing Godly going on. I believe there is something supernatural and it scares me.
I almost visited the lady from Cleveland when I lived there. She had billboards in Slavic Village near downtown where the Eastern European, extremely Catholic community lives. Many people thought she was real. I thank God that I was not caught up in it.
Who is the person you know? FReepmail me if you don't want it public.
So, you are saying "these" are the last days? The first disciples of Christ believed that they were living in the "last days" and that was 2000 years ago. These may feel like the last days but only God knows when that day will come. In the meantime, there have been many examples of bleeding icons. In each instance where the blood was analyzed, it was ALWAYS AB. This particular situation just happens to be better documented and scientifically examined than the others.
>>These may feel like the last days but only God knows when that day will come.<<
Amen!
And also, God's time is not our time.
Here is a joke I heard at Rosary Makers..
A man talks to God and says, "Lord, how long is a million years to you?"
Our Lord says, "Just a minute."
Then the man asks, "How much money is a million dollars to you?"
Our Lord says, "Just a penny."
The man, being very smug says, "Then all I ask is a penny."
Our Lord replies, "In a minute."
We may be in the last days, but we do not know how long a Heavenly Day is!
The local Bishop has said many times that nothing supernatural is happening there. He is wrong only in the fact that there is nothing Godly going on. I believe there is something supernatural and it scares me."
It's creepy and unconscienable that those continue to exploit the charade not only for greed, but for helping Satan in his deceptions.
The CC ought not ONLY "disapprove," but should officially make it anathema.
The priest of my former parish went on a pilgrimage there last year, everyone thought it was just wonderful. The Bishop had no problem with it. Sigh.
Note "her" quotes at the following link:
http://www.creationists.org/MessagesFromHeaven/apparition_claim/savior.html
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.