Agree entirely! We can only know of Him, we can't know entirely. It seems as though we're not in disagreement about the big things, we just don't agree on the small things.
So, is God subject to logic of Creation or is he outside of the laws of this world?
God is not subject to anything we can comprehend. Only His own Being must He not contradict.
Have you ever looked at the world around you and the sky above? Does any of that make "sense" to you? Is it rational to have billions of galaxies spinning in endless vacuum?
Yes. Some. Why not?
We couldn't even begin to contradict Him, even if it were possible!
Yes. Some. Why not?
Because we don't design anything even close. As far as we can tell, the entire Creation is going around in circles! No beginning and no end! Do our houses, clothes, machines, or roads look anylthing like His Creation? I don't think so. So, if His design "makes sense" to you -- you are above and beyond all human beings.