[Mershon]

"I meant John XXIII.
I think Oddi made his "recollection" out of whole cloth."

Ah yes, Sinkspur accuses the good Cardinal, of Happy Memory, whom I am certain Sinky remember as one of the signees of the "Ottaviani Intervention" lied, apparently with no proof whatsoever.

What a magnanimous, loving, charitable heart this post-Vatican II church has produced. Sinky says the good Cardinal lied in a public forum with no evidence whatsoever.

Slander or detraction, anyone?

[sinkspur]

How convenient for Oddi to quote John XXIII 23 years after his death.

Let's just say that the circumstances are odd. Even you would have to admit that.

[sinkspur]

Ah yes, Sinkspur accuses the good Cardinal, of Happy Memory, whom I am certain Sinky remember as one of the signees of the "Ottaviani Intervention" lied, apparently with no proof whatsoever.

The Ottaviani intervention, which Ottaviani later renounced?