Here is a thread that ran about 3 years ago on the subject --- it will give you a flavor of the acerbic reaction that it received from the Romanistas. It would be interesting to run it again.
oh ok thank you for this. It looks fairly old. I recognize some of the names of posters of old.
Just read the whole thing. Very entertaining. No need to post anything else. I got the gyst of how it would go.
“In response to mounting demand, however, Pius finally permitted rigorous scientific examination of the bones in 1956. It emerged that the remains were actually bones of three different people, along with scores of animals. Of the humans, two were men in their 50s, and one was a woman in her 70s. Clearly, these were not the fisherman’s bones.”
http://www.catholicdigest.org/stories/200105052a.html