Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

No Longer the Third Rail. Immigration makes a political comeback in California.
NRO ^ | October 09, 2003, 8:31 a.m. | Mark Krikorian

Posted on 10/09/2003 8:22:00 AM PDT by .cnI redruM

Good politicians try to avoid the pitfall of believing their own press releases. But Republicans in California have spent the past decade believing their opponents' press releases, at least with regard to immigration.

Conventional wisdom among the elite has been that the GOP collapsed in the state because Gov. Pete Wilson made a Faustian bargain in his 1994 reelection campaign by latching on to Proposition 187, which barred illegal aliens from access to many public services. He won, but as the story goes, the party has been getting clobbered there ever since because Hispanic voters turned on them.

As a result, Republicans followed the Democrats' playbook on immigration in the next two gubernatorial elections; neither Dan Lungren in 1998 (who won only 38 percent of the vote) nor Bill Simon in 2002 (42 percent) said anything critical about immigration's massive impact on the state. They were wiped out, and the Democrats took every statewide office and majorities in both houses of the legislature. This time, immigration was one of the signature issues of the campaign, and a Republican won.

So, let's see — GOP uses immigration in 1994, and wins. GOP concedes the issue to the Democrats in 1998 and 2002, and is annihilated. GOP uses immigration again in 2003, and wins. Does anyone notice a pattern here?

The very first issue that arose when Arnold entered the race was his past support for Prop. 187 — which he did not back away from. Even worse, the demonic Pete Wilson was cochairman of Arnold's campaign, and most of Arnold's staff were former Wilson people. Also, Arnold immediately denounced the new law granting driver's licenses to illegal aliens, signed by Gov. Davis in a desperate attempt to shore up Hispanic support. And to top it off, Arnold's main opponent to succeed Davis was a well-known Hispanic Democrat who had taken the lead in opposing Prop. 187.

There was obviously a lot more going on in this election than immigration, but if the bipartisan consensus had been correct about illegal immigration being radioactive for Republicans, Arnold could not have won. And yet, not only did he win, but he and the other major candidate who had something critical to say about illegal immigration — State Sen. Tom McClintock — got a combined total of 62 percent of the vote.

It would be hard to deny that their opposition to illegal immigration helped energize many voters to go to the polls; a CNN exit poll showed that 70 percent of voters opposed the driver's-license law, while only 24 percent supported it. Another poll found that 30 percent of voters said Davis's support for the driver's-license bill made them more likely to support his recall, while only 8 percent said the opposite. In fact, Arnold's opposition to illegal-alien driver's licenses may well have helped some conservatives overlook his liberal stands on social issues.

Heck, Arnold even won 30 percent of the Hispanic vote, and McClintock (who is much more hard-nosed on immigration) won another 9 percent, for a combined Republican total of 39 percent. That's more of the Hispanic vote than George W. Bush got when he ran for reelection as governor of Texas in 1998.

When the illegal-immigration issue was activated by the driver's-license law, blue-collar Democrats were given added reason to turn on Davis. A late September Los Angeles Times poll showed that illegal immigration in general or the driver's-license issue specifically were the top issue for only 6 percent of college-educated Democrats, but among those without a college degree they were the top issue for nearly four times as many. This was part of the reason union voters abandoned Davis; immigration is the ideal Reagan-Democrat issue, tapping as it does into class and social concerns. It's the Democrats who run the risk of irrelevancy if they don't respond to their constituents' concerns on immigration.

Now, Arnold doesn't really have a full-fledged stance on immigration. Repeal of the driver's-license bill is Step 9 in his 10-Step/100-Days agenda, but other than that it's wall-to-wall clichés: "Immigrants contribute to the richness of life in California"; "I will work with federal officials to address this problem"; "Human Traffickers and smugglers exploit and endanger immigrants, and I will crack down on this problem." And, in fact, on one salient immigration-related issue, Arnold is on the wrong side, supporting in-state tuition for illegal aliens going to state universities.

But the specifics are for later — what mattered on Tuesday was that Republican candidates addressed the immigration issue, however narrowly, and it helped propel the party to victory. Maybe the White House and the GOP leadership in Congress will take a lesson from this about the politics of immigration.


TOPICS: Culture/Society; Extended News; Government; News/Current Events; US: California
KEYWORDS: calgov2002; catrans; immigrantlist; immigration; recall
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-34 next last
Arnold accomplished what a lot of smart people haven't. He produced a position on immigration that moved us away from a stupid, all or nothing mentality. Yes, America, the border can be effectively managed without depriving anyone of anything. We don't have to give anyone from anywhere a CA driver's license just for showing up.

Arnold might have even clinched it on just this issue. Republicans should challange the stupid, irrational 'freedom riders' as the lawbreakers that they are. The border can be managed both effectively and humanely.

1 posted on 10/09/2003 8:22:00 AM PDT by .cnI redruM
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: All
These Guys Don't Want You To Donate!

Tick them off! Donate Here By Secure Server

Or mail checks to
FreeRepublic , LLC
PO BOX 9771
FRESNO, CA 93794

or you can use

PayPal at Jimrob@psnw.com

STOP BY AND BUMP THE FUNDRAISER THREAD-
It is in the breaking news sidebar!

2 posted on 10/09/2003 8:22:57 AM PDT by Support Free Republic (Your support keeps Free Republic going strong!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: *immigrant_list; A Navy Vet; Lion Den Dan; Free the USA; Libertarianize the GOP; madfly; B4Ranch; ..
ping
3 posted on 10/09/2003 9:24:23 AM PDT by gubamyster
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: .cnI redruM; Marine Inspector; FITZ; Ajnin; Pelham; Travis McGee; sarcasm; harpseal; RonDog; ...
Arnold accomplished what a lot of smart people haven't. He produced a position on immigration that moved us away from a stupid, all or nothing mentality.

Not even close to the truth.

Arnold's real position on Illegals, which was stealthily available during the campaign, was unveiled during his press conference yesterday...

"There's a bill that Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) has introduced that I think is terrific. It gives temporary working permits to immigrants so they can come in and out of this country, out of this state, and also, you know, there's another idea. Undocumented immigrants who come here before August 2003 can apply for visas especially if they don't have a criminal background. And if they have a job right now, they can apply for that visa. So there are different programs I want to push in that direction to help undocumented immigrants."
LINK

Who does Arnold think he's supposed to represent, citizens or Illegals?

His issue with the Ilegal Alien drivers' licenses is the lack of background checks, not that they are Illegals who don't belong here. He wants them to be redesignated as "guest workers." Now you understand his reluctance to support the Save Our License referendum.

Arnold supports Amnesty for Illegals, while claiming that he doesn't. He's thrown in with the McCain-Hatch-Cornyn wing of the GOP.

Get ready for a real intra-party civil war as the appeasers try to sneak their Amnesty by other names trhough the Congress.

They are all woefully out of touch with the electorate...

The Luntz Poll (http://capwiz.com/fair/utr/1/NASACDSZKP/MEGUCDSZLJ/ commissioned by the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR), showed strong disfavor - 68 percent to 21 percent - for granting licenses to illegal aliens, and that disapproval was on the minds of many voters as they went to the polls.

By a large majority, voters who participated in the recall election said they would support a proposed referendum on next March's ballot to block implementation of the law granting driver's licenses to illegal aliens. Sixty-two percent indicated that were such a referendum to appear on the ballot it would win their vote, while only 25 percent said they would oppose it.

< -snip- >

Davis' decision to sign the driver's license bill, after twice vetoing similar measures, was not the only flip-flop on matters relating to illegal immigration that hurt him with voters. After initially opposing in-state tuition for illegal aliens at state-run universities, Davis ultimately signed legislation allowing illegal aliens to qualify for subsidized tuition rates. That decision was opposed by 73 percent of the people who voted in Tuesday's recall, while only 18 percent said they favored the idea.

During the course of the campaign, the media repeatedly asserted that Governor-elect Arnold Schwarzenegger's support for the 1994 voter initiative, known as Proposition 187, was a political liability for the candidate. The Luntz survey indicates otherwise. By a 65 percent to 26 percent margin, voters said that illegal aliens "should not be eligible for services and benefits provided by state and local governments, except for emergency services." Prop. 187, which included almost identical language, received 59 percent of the vote nine years ago.
LINK


4 posted on 10/09/2003 9:44:12 AM PDT by Sabertooth (No Drivers' Licences for Illegal Aliens. Petition SB60. http://www.saveourlicense.com/n_home.htm)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Sabertooth; *calgov2002; AuntB; jam137; GmbyMan; DoctorZIn; fooman; PeoplesRep_of_LA; ...
Thanks for the info!

OFFICIAL BUMP(TOPIC)LIST

5 posted on 10/09/2003 9:48:58 AM PDT by Ernest_at_the_Beach (Davis needs to get out of Arnoold's Office)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: Sabertooth
Who does Arnold think he's supposed to represent, citizens or Illegals?

With David Dreier advising him, you know the answer all too well.

6 posted on 10/09/2003 9:56:39 AM PDT by Pelham
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: Sabertooth
SB60 bump
7 posted on 10/09/2003 10:00:46 AM PDT by brightx
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: Sabertooth
Thanks, Saber. Important info.
8 posted on 10/09/2003 10:08:37 AM PDT by Bernard Marx
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: Sabertooth
The issue is getting those who come here to get visas, job permits so they can go by the law, pay taxes or get out.

It is the right move.

What do you object to?
9 posted on 10/09/2003 10:18:10 AM PDT by A CA Guy (God Bless America, God bless and keep safe our fighting men and women.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: Ernest_at_the_Beach
REPOST: I believe three events, soft-pedalled by the media, had a huge impact on Davis and the Dumbocrats and helped Arnold immeasurably:

(A) Clinton's presence, campaigning at Davis' side (he also made radio ads for Davis), was a dud. Remember that Davis went on national TV and cravenly pled for BillyBoy's presence. We must spread the word that Clinton actually helped Cali boot Davis out of office;

(B) Davis' craven hyphenate pandering by signing the illegal aliens auto licensing law backfired on him bigtime, as did the triple increase in auto registration costs;

(C) Cruz Bustamente's hyphenate pander by accepting millions from Indian casinos was also a major misfire.

Since Cali is usually about five years ahead of the Nation, if the Dumbos playing the diversity card in multi-cultural hyphenated Cali is backfiring, there is hope elsewhere. We have got to take the hyphens out of American politics and live as one, united Nation as the Founders intended. We must support Tom Tancredo's call for an end to hyphenated caucuses in the Congress.

I wonder if graydavis dashed off that note to Bill Clinton yet in which he thanks BillyBoy for coming to Cali to campaign for him. Bill was so faithful appearing at Gray's side for a lot of photo-ops. Billy even made radio ads for Gray. " Dear Bill," Davis might write, "You were a big help. Thanks for nothing. " Gray.

In 2002 Bill (and Hil's) campaigning had a hugely negative effect on candidates and caused unimaginable losses for the Dims including the Senate majority. Yet they still drag out this has-been to campaign. Will they never learn? Clinton's little more than a one-trick pony who's way past his prime. Put him out to pasture. Now.

10 posted on 10/09/2003 10:19:32 AM PDT by Liz
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: A CA Guy
What do you object to?

Simple, get your work permit and your visa before you come. Millions of people have done it, why can't they?

11 posted on 10/09/2003 11:19:19 AM PDT by Pa' fuera
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: .cnI redruM
Huh?

We can talk about illegal immigration again?

Sure can't tell from the title.

12 posted on 10/09/2003 11:20:06 AM PDT by Publius6961 (40% of Californians are as dumb as a sack of rocks.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Sabertooth
Arnold is another notch in George Bush's belt. It doesn't really matter what Americans want anymore. Amnesty of any kind will bring on the next 10 million stomping over the border.
13 posted on 10/09/2003 11:25:19 AM PDT by janetgreen (Attention Mr. President: America is being invaded. WAKE UP!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: janetgreen
Amnesty of any kind will bring on the next 10 million stomping over the border.

Exactly. The newly-legalized will become obsolete because they will command higher wages. The next wave of illegals will get the jobs because they will work for less. The newly-legalized will then feed off the government trough for sustenance.

14 posted on 10/09/2003 11:41:23 AM PDT by Pa' fuera
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 13 | View Replies]

To: Sabertooth
From the SF Chronicle: Is there any question that the people's recall has been HIJACKED by new world order RINO's?
15 posted on 10/09/2003 12:17:26 PM PDT by flamefront (To the victor go the oils. No oil or oil-money for islamofascist weapons of mass annihilation.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: Pelham
With David Dreier advising him, you know the answer all too well.

Somebody should take Dreier on in the primary over this issue. I am convinced if his constituents knew what a complete sell-out he is they'd dump his pink butt so fast it would make his blow-dried hair move. We need to defeat a couple politicians on the illegal immigration issue. Congressmen love being congressmen, if they thought the voters would throw them out over this issue they might straighten up and fly right.

16 posted on 10/09/2003 12:25:31 PM PDT by justanotherfreeper
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies]

To: justanotherfreeper
Yup. The RNC apparently didn't get the message when Spence Abraham lost his Senate seat over this issue.
17 posted on 10/09/2003 1:22:02 PM PDT by Pelham
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 16 | View Replies]

To: Sabertooth
"It gives temporary working permits..., and also, you know, there's another idea"

Maybe it doesn't mean anything, but AS's phrase 'you know' is eerily similiar to hitlery's usual tip off that she's lying or pulling one over on the sheeple again.

18 posted on 10/09/2003 2:02:53 PM PDT by Paulie
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: Pa' fuera
I AGREE, and I think Arnold is going that way but giving those here a chance to apply legally before being kicked out on their arse.
19 posted on 10/09/2003 2:14:29 PM PDT by A CA Guy (God Bless America, God bless and keep safe our fighting men and women.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | View Replies]

To: A CA Guy
The issue is getting those who come here to get visas, job permits so they can go by the law, pay taxes or get out.

It is the right move.

What do you object to?

I object to rewarding criminality.

The issue isn't as you say, it's for foreigners to get their visas and job permist before they get here.

What you and Scwharzenegger are advocating is akin to renting a room to a burglar after he's already moved in.


20 posted on 10/09/2003 2:39:18 PM PDT by Sabertooth (No Drivers' Licences for Illegal Aliens. Petition SB60. http://www.saveourlicense.com/n_home.htm)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-34 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson