Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: supercat
Compelling argument, but there is a plausible counter which should be dealt with: in some religions, it is believed that the soul is stuck in the body until the body is cremated or otherwise destroyed (the exact requirements vary by religion).

And the exact beliefs vary by religion.

You are saying we should consider many, greatly varying theologies. That is a daunting task.

If you care to tell me the beliefs of the individual theologies about souls , I'd be willing to see what I can learn about them.

Since those religions disagree with one another, a "one size" answer to their concerns will not fit them all.

If you want a more general answer, right now, I'd say: Why the hurry to release the soul? Does it get reused right away? Does it attain bliss right away? Does "right away" even matter in the scheme of eternity?

Does "languishment" hurt the indestructible soul somehow?

Is a languishing soul trapped in time? Does that bother it? Or is the soul always part of the eternal sphere (wheel) , no matter where it is at?

I only brought up souls because right-to-diers are (pretend to be?) so concerned about souls.

Right-to-diers who make the news, like Nancy Cruzan's father and George Felos, talk about releasing the person/soul from their body.

It would likely be kinder to the patients if medical experts who are concerned with severely disabled patients, dealt with them primarily as physical persons and tried to help them in anyway they could and, perhaps, looked to the future with hope for a recovery.

It seems like some of them use the excuse of the soul to kill the body.

One of the underlying arguments of the right-to-diers seems to be

We can't make a "mistake" when we kill someone."

"It's all right if we kill patients. It's all right if we err in killing patients. The patients' souls will "live on" or "be reincarnated" anyway....We can't make a mistake in killing them.


We've had fault-free divorce.
We've had fault-free auto-insurance
Now we have fault-free medical killing.

603 posted on 09/26/2003 5:51:46 AM PDT by syriacus (Terri can feel --- and she'd like a meal.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 596 | View Replies ]


To: syriacus
I think it is irrelevant to Terri's case right now and will not help to discuss this subject of souls, etc. I'll stay extensional here but I find it distasteful to be even talking about it because IMO Felos is a total, excuse the term, moron.
614 posted on 09/26/2003 7:19:46 AM PDT by pc93 (http://www.terrisfight.org)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 603 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson