If my reasoning is short sighted (in your subjective opinion), then yours is incredibly draconian and incompatible with a free society. Since when do we judge people based on which group identity they belong to? Would you think it's fair to condemn all white male Christians based on the aberrant behavior of Timothy McVeigh or Eric Robert Rudolph? I would hope not.
Besides having barely any nexus to the original thread topic, the rest of your post is just mendacious bloviating. More of the typical unsubstantiated anti-gay slander. It's getting really old here. It's time for you to grow up.
People with deadly communicable diseases have been quarentined for almost as long as this country has existed.