Globalisation Erodes Local Languages, Fuels 'Glocal' English

A continent that contains a third of the world's spoken codes -- and yet one whose astonishing diversity of speech and written systems -- is being eroded by relentless globalisation. That, in a nutshell, is the ethnolinguist's lament for Asia.

SINGAPORE, Jul 30 (IPS) - A continent that contains a third of the world's spoken codes -- and yet one whose astonishing diversity of speech and written systems -- is being eroded by relentless globalisation. That, in a nutshell, is the ethnolinguist's lament for Asia.

”In South-east Asia, the response to globalisation is to acquire language skills, not in many languages, but in one, the English language, which is seen as the key to success in the globalised age,” said Dr Rujaya Abhakorn, lecturer in South-east Asian history at Chiang Mai University, Thailand.

It is indeed English, which served the colonial British empire and now drives the knowledge economy and the Internet, that is all too often seen as a tyrannosaurus rex that voraciously gobbles up cultures and traditions. ”Efficiency and development, growth and human capital, are not tolerant of difference,” commented Prof Joseph Lo Bianco, director of The National Language and Literacy Institute of Australia. ”Globalised modernisation requires that knowledge is imparted in ways that are comparable across differences of setting, culture and language.”

Abhakorn and Lo Bianco were participants at a conference on language trends in Asia, held this month by the National University of Singapore's Asia Research Institute. The discussion focused on the sorts of globalisation in Asia today, and whether or not the primary language of an economy is endangering other languages.

Generally, some participants pointed out, the endangerment of language is most serious where local globalisation is the most advanced and includes virtually all economic sectors.

Against such a background, the future of languages such as Hovongan, in north-central Kalimantan, Indonesia, and Sou, in the southern Laos province of Attapeu, is in peril - both are estimated to have around 1,000 speakers, and thus classified as being endangered under the definition of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation (UNESCO).

”Our language has been ripped from the world,” Goenawan Mohamad, founding editor of the Jakarta-based 'Tempo' newsmagazine, wrote in a paper presented at the meeting, ”stripped of shape, smell, colour and form, cleansed of the grit and grafitti, the rumpus and commotion that make up real life''.

Even where languages are not endangered, there are confrontations between them and English.

Dr Udaya Narayan Singh, director of the Central Institute of Indian Languages in Mysore, India, provided a background to the diversity and linguistic politics of the country.

”Even when 80 percent of all Indians speak one or another major Indian language, and Hindi is understood by close to 60 percent,” said Singh, ”there are still many other languages with a long literary history, grammatical tradition and rich heritage, and they are still in use in all modern means of communication.”

”Bilingualism in India,” he told IPS, ”is not just due to economic causes but also due to conflict.”

The official language of communication of India is Hindi. But, Singh explained, ''There is always a hidden tussle as well as open confrontation between supporters of Hindi who mostly oppose the use of English, and supporters of the regional languages who look to English as an alternative link between the Indian states.''

Globalisation has also brought about what has been called the 'McDonaldisation' of societies, most notably through the entry of cultural products like Hollywood movies, U.S. toys, fast food and pop music.

Anthony Reid, director of the Asia Research Institute, however noted that although media is one of the potent forces of globalisation today, it has been beneficial in the past.

For instance, he explained, radio and cheap cassettes have helped non-national language communities in Indonesia, East Malaysia, the Philippines, Burma and India.

”Cassettes and radio invigorated and helped standardise the verbal expression of the language even as its written expression was being lost,” said Reid. ”In diaspora, even isolated speakers could remain in touch with their musical traditions with a portable stereo and a few cassettes.”

Indeed, Lo Bianco commented that new communication processes have arisen that link tribal, small and localised languages to ecological sustainability, or which seek to give these languages political recognition within human rights paradigms. This has also occurred during the 1990s as a means of stemming ”the cataclysmic loss of the world's linguistic heritage, a vast proportion of this in the Asian region”, he said.

Like plant and animal species, endangered languages are confined to small areas. More than 80 percent of countries with great biological diversity are also the places with the greatest number of endangered languages.

The need for protection has never been more urgent - many of the world's endangered plant and animal species today, for example, are known only to certain peoples whose languages are also dying out.

Even so, there are parallel globalisations, as Prof Chua Beng Huat of the National University of Singapore, observed.

”In entertainment, one is looking at a very conscious effort of an industry globalising itself,” he said. ”In East Asia, where Singapore is culturally placed because of its Chinese-dominant population, the idea that we are being westernised/Americanised is being disrupted.”

Chua said that fans of products such as pop music from Japan or television soaps from Korea claim it is easier than watching Hollywood: ”You can't be white but you can move yourself from Singapore to Taiwan; the dominant language is not English but 'different Chinese', depending on where it's put together. Are these programmes in fact reactions to globalisation, and nationalistic?”

One reaction to the conventional idea of globalisation, as pointed out by Anne Pakir, an associate professor at the National University of Singapore, is that English is ”going 'glocal', that is, going global while maintaining local roots”. She sees 'glocal English' as a language that has international status but which also expresses local identities.

Already, more Asians speak English than anyone else, and the kinds of Asian English multiply every year. For the many who continue to see it as an intrusion, a destructive force, there may be some solace to be found in the old Malay saying - 'your mouth is your tiger'. (END)

I thought one world language was always a great liberal ideal. Was not that the impetus behind Esparanto?

Yup. But a lot of these guys don't root for the home team. Its not as if Esparanto was reported to be linguistically rich, either. It takes time for a rich language to develop.

I never understood the great lament over extinction; plants animals or languages. When something becomes extinct, its place is taken by something naturally selected as superior.

Languages continually vanish. Are these cunning linguists calling for these isolated people to maintain their language when there is no one else with which to speak it?

It is characteristically modernist. They believe there is something intrisically valuable about the form of speech, not the ideas it conveys. Aristotle said words are a symbol of an impression on the soul. Here we see an undue importance attached to the symbol, not the truth it may represent.

I lived in various parts of Europe for seven years and I was always curious as to how English "sounded" to people. It's impossible for people born into English to grasp its sound since meaning intrudes.

Germans told me it sounds sloppy, but the most interesting answer was from a Polish woman: "It sounds musical." That not only surprised me but set me to thinking that part of its universality is tied to its use in pop music.

I thought one world language was always a great liberal ideal.

Yep, as long as it's not English. For a look at why, see:
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/957249/posts

"its use in pop music."

HA, you remind me of something I've always wondered about, why don't British rock & roll singers seem to have a British accent when they sing? Think of Mick Jagger, for example, or Elton John. They have quite pronounced accents when speaking, but when singing they could certainly be American.

Or is this just my imagination (running away with me)?

It's understandable how foreign cultures might see English as a threat. Imagine if we Americans were told that French was still the international language and that we must master French to communicate on the Internet. Yikes!

Well, assuming all of us on this thread so far are native English speakers...let's consider ourselves lucky. When it comes to learning English, for many people it's a royal pain in the a$$. Very much different from someone taking up French, Italian, or Spanish... A German friend of mine calls English the "language of exceptions."

It's understandable how foreign cultures might see English as a threat.

I don't buy that argument. Primitive cultures don't care because they don't have long-term views or content (for the most part). Poor cultures don't care because English is a ticket to a better life. Adaptive cultures don't care because English is just part of their operating environment.

It gives the French heartburn because for awhile they packaged themselves as the pinnacle of civilization, and the Americans are France's chosen political whipping boy (since at least WWII).

However, I do consider myself as an American to be extremely fortunate.

Germans told me it sounds sloppy
That's because it's a mutt language. For six or seven hunderd years everybody and their third cousin who didn't have anything better to do invaded the british isles.
I've also been told that it's one of the hardest to learn as for every rule there are (at least)two execptions.

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.