[Mamzelle]

Good grief, takes with one hand and gives with the other. This is so absurd--a ruling to confuse and increase litigation. I'd be happier if it had gone all the way to undergrad--at least there'd be more than smoke to fight...

[XJarhead]

Heh. Put down my prediction of a split decision just as it popped up here. O'Connor makes me want to retch. I'd have more respect for someone who was more liberal but at least applied some consistent principles. She's just a legislator sitting on the bench.

[texson66]

Good grief, takes with one hand and gives with the other. This is so absurd--a ruling to confuse and increase litigation. I'd be happier if it had gone all the way to undergrad--at least there'd be more than smoke to fight...

That's why Congress and the Supreme Court exist: to employ more lawyers!