Replies

They pay sales taxes and other non-income taxes and fees and payroll taxes if they work. So, the money they get back is from those taxes they payed. Everybody is getting back money that was payed in the form of one tax or another. I could be wrong.

You are wrong. We all pay sales taxes and other non-income taxes and fees. Payroll taxes are paid by purchasers, clients etc..This was supposed to be an "income" tax refund not a give away from producers to non-producers.

You are wrong.

Your response says that but it doesn't show that.

We all pay sales taxes and other non-income taxes and fees. Payroll taxes are paid by purchasers, clients etc..

They are all taxes and not income taxes, so they all apply to my suggestion.

This was supposed to be an "income" tax refund not a give away from producers to non-producers.

You obviously copied the wrong answer from a previous poster. I'm not talking about the leaches who never give and only take. I'm talking about people who don't pay income taxes but who work and produce at jobs and have payroll taxes paid for their work and who pay sales taxes and other taxes and fees. That is the money I'm referring to, not the money that you and I pay as income taxes. Doesn't the GOP want people to keep more of their tax money? If so, then a working person who doesn't earn enough to pay income tax still has to pay other taxes and should also be able to keep more of their tax money. Yes? No? Why?