Posted on 05/31/2003 4:05:21 PM PDT by John W
PITTSBURGH (AP) - A group wants Congress to test whether cash incentives would encourage more families to donate the organs of relatives following their deaths. The Pittsburgh-based group wants a 1984 law prohibiting financial incentives for organ donations to be rewritten to allow a project that would award $5,000 to families who authorize a deceased relative's organs to be used for transplantation.
The unnamed coalition of transplant surgeons, academics, religious leaders and activists sent a letter Wednesday to 40 senators and members of Congress.
"It would just greatly increase the number of organs that are donated," Harold Kyriazi, a University of Pittsburgh neuroscientist who organized the group, said Friday.
The idea for cash incentives comes at a time when leaders in the field of organ procurement are pushing for changes to reverse a trend that has seen donations remain flat in recent years.
The Virginia-based United Network for Organ Sharing says more than 6,000 people died last year waiting for organs. More than 80,000 people are currently awaiting transplants.
Under the proposal, representatives for organ procurement agencies would approach families after a relative has been pronounced brain dead and offer the $5,000 "as a way of saying thank you for giving the gift of life." The money would go to the deceased person's estate.
The coalition's letter was first reported Friday in the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review.
Dr. Thomas Peters, a transplant surgeon in Jacksonville, Fla., who signed the proposal, said only about half the families approached each year about donating a deceased relative's organs agree to do so.
Families often have the final say about organ donations, even if someone signs an organ donor card during life.
"Financial incentives should be studied in well-controlled and appropriately designed trials. That's all we're asking - that this approach be given a try," Peters said.
Both United Network for Organ Sharing - the nonprofit organization that administers the nation's organ procurement network - and the American Medical Association have called for studies of financial incentives for organ donations.
But UNOS spokeswoman Anne Paschke said her organization is not prepared to back any specific project yet, believing the details need to be carefully worked out. Some focus has been shifted back toward more traditional ways of getting people to donate organs.
How exactly does this work? My understanding is that organs, to be useful for transplantation, need to be removed very close to the time of death. So when are the relatives--not the dying person, I notice--to give the consent? Within moments of death? Or prior to death?
This path leads to nothing but evil.
A liver! ... A liver!... My kingdom for a liver!!!I'll see your kidney and raise you a pancreas.
Psssstt! Wanna buy a heart? I got an extra here and it's gonna go bad if it's not used pretty soon. Tell ya what... take the heart, I'll toss in a right lung for free!!
Awwww... c'mon... have a heart.
Reread the first two sentences of the article. The incentives are aimed at the families of the deceased, who are to "authorize" the organ donation.
Agreed, but... why don't more people donate?? As far as I'm concerned the instant I've shuffled off this mortal coil it's worthless to me. If any of it helps somebody else to a better or longer future... why not? (OTOH, I insist that it be my choice, for the obvious reasons.)
How about because if you're in an accident and borderline, there's less incentive for a hospital to keep working on you if they find an organ donor card in your wallet......
Other nations are already doing it....
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.