Posted on 05/30/2003 5:41:15 AM PDT by runningbear
Prosecutors want autopsy results unsealed
Prosecutors want autopsy results unsealed
By JOHN COTÉ and GARTH STAPLEY
BEE STAFF WRITERS
Published: May 29, 2003, 07:40:54 PM PDT
Prosecutors have reversed their position and are now asking a judge to unseal autopsy reports for Laci Peterson and her unborn son after details allegedly from one report were leaked to the media Thursday.
“The information being leaked has clearly been skewed in favor of the defense,” prosecution documents filed in court Thursday say. “The People cannot see why the autopsy documents should not be released.”
Defense attorney Mark Geragos strongly denied the leak came from his team. "I don’t know who they got the document from and I certainly didn’t want the document public," Geragos said.
The prosecutors’ shift on the autopsy reports came after NBC News reported they had obtained “a portion of the coroner’s report on the autopsy on the fetus.”
The document says the fetus was found with 1 1/2 loops of plastic tape around its neck and had a significant cut on its torso that had been inflicted after death, MSNBC reported on its Web site.
The information could be used to bolster a defense theory that Laci and her unborn child were slain in a ritualistic killing, possibly by Satanic cult members.
Stanislaus County Judge Al Girolami had ordered the autopsy reports tentatively sealed on May 15 at the request of prosecution and defense attorneys. He was scheduled to make a final decision on the sealing by today.
A statement released Thursday from the district attorney’s office says prosecutors “cannot verify the accuracy of any media statements concerning the contents of the autopsy reports without violating the court’s order.”
Senior Deputy District Attorney Dave Harris had argued in favor of sealing the documents at a Tuesday hearing, saying it was necessary to protect Scott Peterson’s right to a fair trial.
Charity Kenyon, an attorney representing a coalition of newspaper organizations, including The Bee, said during the hearing that the public’s right to view court documents was a fundamental component of a transparent legal system.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Peterson D.A. wants autopsies released
Prosecutor appeals to judge after reports leaked
Peterson D.A. wants autopsies released
Prosecutor appeals to judge after reports leaked
Suzanne Herel, Chronicle Staff Writer Friday, May 30, 2003
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A frustrated Stanislaus County district attorney did an about-face Thursday and asked a judge to release autopsy reports on Laci Peterson and her unborn son, saying that leaks about the condition of the baby's body were "skewed in favor of the defense."
District Attorney Jim Brazelton stopped just short of accusing defense attorneys for Scott Peterson -- who have hinted that a satanic gang was responsible for killing Laci Peterson and the couple's unborn baby -- of leaking selected details from the autopsy. But in asking a judge to lift a seal on the document, Brazelton said prosecutors hadn't released the document, even to Modesto police or to Laci Peterson's family.
Brazelton filed court papers to make the autopsy public hours after the cable news outlet MSNBC reported that the unborn baby had been found with a loop and a half of plastic tape around his neck and that there was a "significant cut" on his torso inflicted after death.
"The information being leaked has clearly been skewed in favor of the defense," Brazelton, who originally had asked for the autopsies to be sealed, said in his motion Thursday. "By releasing the autopsy reports, the court will allow the media to see what the actual facts are, and then accurate information may be reported."
Superior Court Judge Al Girolami is scheduled to hear the motion June 6.
Mark Geragos, who is defending Scott Peterson on capital murder charges that he killed his wife and their unborn son, did not return phone calls to his office Thursday, but told the Associated Press that he would not comment on the reports.
Girolami "more than telegraphed that he does not want us commenting on the case" during a closed meeting in his chambers Tuesday, Geragos told the AP.
INFORMATION NOT CONFIRMED
The Contra Costa County Sheriff's Department, whose coroner conducted the autopsies, would not confirm or deny the information in the leaked report.
The bodies of Laci Peterson, 27, and her unborn son, whom the couple had planned to name Conner, were found in mid-April after washing ashore along the Richmond shoreline.
MSNBC, which did not say who had supplied.....
---------------------------------------------------------------
Grisly Questions
Autopsy Shows Badly Decomposed Laci Peterson
May 30— Laci Peterson's head and parts of her limbs were missing and plastic tape was wrapped around the neck of her child, according to the full autopsy and coroner's photographs exclusively seen by ABCNEWS.
According to the autopsy, the skin of the child was not decomposed at all, though the right side of his body was mutilated, and the placenta and umbilical cord were not found with the body.
The autopsy said that the cause of Laci Peterson's death was undetermined, and there was no evidence of man-made wounds, despite the fact that her head and all or part of her limbs were missing.
Peterson's body was so badly decomposed it barely looked like a body after it was found in San Francisco Bay last month. However, the autopsy report showed her cervix was intact.
Experts are divided over whether the new revelations about the condition of Laci Peterson's body and that of her child will help prosecutors or Scott Peterson's defense.
On Thursday, sources close to the investigation told ABCNEWS the sealed autopsy report indicated a piece of nylon tape was looped around the child's neck when it washed ashore last month, and that there was a laceration or tear on the tiny body.
There also was tape on Laci Peterson's lower torso, outside her clothing, when her body was found April 14, a day after her baby's remains were recovered, the sources said.
Forensic pathologist Dr. Michael Baden told Good Morning America that the limbs and head were probably removed before Laci was put in the water.
The grisly new details could fuel speculation as to whether the baby ever lived outside the womb, which defense attorneys could use to undermine the prosecution's case against Scott Peterson, Laci's husband and the father of the child they had planned to name Conner.
The prosecutors handling the case said Thursday that since the autopsy was starting to be leaked to the media, the whole report should be released.
"The information being leaked has clearly been skewed in favor of the defense," Deputy Stanislaus County, Calif., District Attorney David Harris wrote in a statement released late Thursday. "By releasing the autopsy reports the court will allow the media to see what the actual facts are and then accurate information may be reported to mitigate recent adverse publicity."
Unanswered Questions
While the defense and prosecution dispute what the latest revelations might mean, experts also appear divided.
When asked what the tape on the bodies might mean to the case, Robert Pugsley, a law professor at the Southwestern University School of Law in Los Angeles, told ABCNEWS Radio: "This 8-month-old fetus was the direct intended victim, as well as the mother, of the homicidal activities of the murderer.
"This is a clear indication that the state is perfectly justified — indeed, I think, obliged — to pursue the double-homicide case which they've already laid," he said.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DA wants autopsy results made public
DA wants autopsy results made public Fetus had tape around neck
Thursday, May 29, 2003 Posted: 9:48 PM EDT (0148 GMT)
On the Scene: Toobin: Prosecutors calling bluff over autopsy report
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MODESTO, California (CNN) -- On the heels of gruesome information leaked from the autopsy report on Laci Peterson's unborn child, the prosecutor in the case filed a motion Thursday seeking to unseal the reports on both the mother and child so that the media can report "accurate information."
Stanislaus County District Attorney James Brazelton said the people of California have the right to correct inaccurate information, suggesting the media reports on the autopsy are not.
"By releasing the autopsy reports, the court will allow the media to see what the actual facts are and then accurate information may be reported to mitigate recent adverse publicity," his motion read.
Brazelton earlier Thursday released a statement, saying he "cannot verify the accuracy of any media statements concerning the contents of the autopsy reports without violating the court's order."
He later decided to file the motion.
"It continues to be the view of the district attorney that the evidence in this case should be presented in court through testimony of witnesses and not selectively leaked to the news media by unknown persons whom the press will not identify," he said.
His motion will be heard June 6 in Superior Court in Modesto.
Scott Peterson, 30, is awaiting trial on two counts of murder for the deaths of his wife Laci, 27, and their unborn son, who was to be named Connor. Prosecutors have said they will seek the death penalty if he is convicted. Peterson insists he is innocent.
Just two days ago, Superior Court Judge Al Girolami heard arguments on whether to keep the autopsy results sealed, with prosecutors and the defense arguing that unsealing them could jeopardize Peterson's chance for a fair trial. News organizations countered by saying the results are a matter of public record and should be released. Girolami did not rule on the matter at that time.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
LACI'S UNBORN BABY HAD A 'NOOSE' AROUND HIS NECK
(((Ah, media sensationalizing the title, my opinion here!)))
LACI'S UNBORN BABY HAD A 'NOOSE' AROUND HIS NECK
By HOWARD BREUER and CYNTHIA R. FAGEN
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
May 30, 2003 -- Laci Peterson's unborn child had plastic tape wrapped around his neck and a large cut across his shoulders when he was found in the shallow waters of San Francisco Bay.
The shocking revelation opens the possibility that the 81/2-month fetus had been born and then strangled, a forensic expert told The Post.
According to sources close to the probe, the boy, who was to be named Conner, was found with 11/2 loops of plastic tape around his neck, with an inch gap in between the tape and the skin - making the tape resemble a noose.
Noted forensics expert Dr. Henry Lee said that would be "with strangulation." Lee, who is not connected with the case, said it was possible the child had been born and then strangled - but cautioned that more details needed to be revealed before he could say conclusively.
The latest blockbuster details were first reported by MSNBC and later confirmed by The Associated Press.
The revelations could bolster the defense's contention that members of a Modesto satanic cult - not Scott Peterson, Laci's husband - killed his wife and unborn child, Lee said.
"This opens up a lot of interesting questions," said the doctor, who provided DNA expertise for the O.J. Simpson double-murder case.
The new headline-grabbing murder mystery has intensified since Laci's headless body washed ashore in San Francisco Bay on April 14. The fetus was retrieved a day earlier.
Sources involved in the case told Fox News that investigators were not ruling out that the plastic tape could have been floating debris that managed to wrap itself around the baby's neck.
Top forensic pathologist Dr. Michael Baden doubts the fetus was actually born, but was still intact in the womb when Laci died. If the baby had been separated, Baden said, the tiny body would have deteriorated faster than Laci's.
Both bodies were found to be in the same condition.
"We just have to wait and see," Baden said.
Reacting to yesterday's stunning autopsy details, District Attorney James Brazelton lashed out at the media, saying that because of the leaks, his office had filed a motion to unseal the full 25-page autopsy report.
"The information leaked has clearly been skewed in favor of the defense," the motion stated.
Peterson, 30, who has pleaded not guilty, is in jail pending his trial on charges of double murder. Mark Geragos, Peterson's defense lawyer, has asserted that a mystery brown van was seen around the Petersons' neighborhood sometime around his 27-year-old wife's disappearance.
The defense also contends it knows at least four or five people who were actually involved in the "satanic" killing.
A preliminary hearing has been set for July 16, when prosecutors will have to show they have sufficient evidence to try Peterson on murder charges. If he is convicted, he could face death by lethal injection.
A spokesman for the Contra Costa County coroner's office left a recording saying officials would not comment.
(Excerpt) Read more at modbee.com ...
Boy, this is getting really down and dirty.
The rochas will have the support of 99% of the people I betcha
"How do we know that Laci didn't committ suicide?"
Let me count the ways, Jeralynn...
sw
The answer is that a circumstantial case can be just as strong as direct evidence.
Is this addressed to me? I was "not courteous to wait"
If you re-read the thread, you will see that no one asked you if you were a lawyer. Carolina Mom addressed that question to me.
It's still circumstancial. And, as far as that goes eyewitness accounts are as unreliable as evidence get's.
Ever play that game where someone walks through the room, says "hello" and then you get to describe what he was wearing?
Because I have common sense.
"Circumstancial" evidence is called "circumstancial" for a reason. Didn't you read my previous post on the subject?
We don't know everything yet...praise God.
sw
I don't know why you insist on continuing to dredge up this "eyewitness" strawman.
It doesn't matter. It's not an either/or situation.
You can have evidence without it being circumstancial or having an eyewitness.
That's meaningless.
My guess is JP did take them perhaps claiming she took them so they didn't get stolen? She had to know they were inherited from Laci's grandma, and why not just give them to Rocha's? I see in the pic of the lamps runningbear posted above, the harp on one of the lamp is askew, and finial is missing...
If someone is shot, the weapon is recovered and balistics prove that weapon was the same one used in the crime..
That's hard evidence. No witnesses or "circumstancial" stuff required.
The tape (for example) is evidence.
A PROTECTIVE ORDER IS ISSUED TOO
"Court Documents Sealing Decision
Posted on Friday, May 30 2003 at 3:48 PM PST ----
A new Superior Court document was added. Click on “Court Docs” menu bar on the left side of this page.
The public document is a “Minute Order” detailing the courts decision (Judge Girolami) on sealing several documents. The court finds that the following documents “Shall Remain Sealed.”
1. Search Warrant and Return of Search Warrant dated April 24, 2003;
2. Affidavit in Support of the Ramey Warrant;
3. Search Warrant, Addendum and Return of Search Warrant dated April 21, 2003;
4. Search Warrant, Addendum and Return of Search Warrant (30-day extension) dated February 27, 2003;
5. Autopsy reports of Laci and Conner Peterson
It is further ordered that the prior orders remain in effect. Specifically, that all of these documents now in the possession of the Prosecution and Defense shall not be released, conveyed, or disclosed to anyone outside of their respective trial teams without further order of the court
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.