Posted on 04/29/2003 1:06:52 PM PDT by tripod
Edited on 07/12/2004 4:02:52 PM PDT by Jim Robinson. [history]
Alexandria public schools administrators have scrapped the Memorial Day holiday this year to make up for class days missed in the winter. The decision upset many teachers, several of whom are veterans or spouses of veterans, especially with service members fighting in Iraq. "It's about people who give their lives for our country. This is about people in wheelchairs," said Hilari Hinnant, a first-grade teacher at John Adams Elementary School whose husband served in the Marine Corps during the Vietnam War. "It's a serious holiday, especially given what our country has been through." Memorial Day is a day of remembrance for those who died in military service. Its roots are disputed, but it was first officially observed May 30, 1868, when flowers were placed on the graves of Union and Confederate soldiers at the Arlington National Cemetery. Jacqualyne Evans Mcrae, a teacher at John Adams school, was part of an Air Force unit stationed in Aviano, Italy, during the 1991 Persian Gulf war, and the traditional holiday holds special meaning for her. But this Memorial Day, May 26, she will be working, while her counterparts in other area school districts will take time off to honor America's war dead. Ms. Evans Mcrae conceded that the day honoring troops may not be much more than a time to hit the pools and parks for some children, but added that the operations in Iraq make it more likely that parents would take the time this year to remind their children about the U.S.-led war efforts and the people involved in the same. "There is the chance for a more open reflection and acknowledgment, and a lot of parents want their children to experience and know about it," she said. "I think more parents would go down to the memorials and monuments." The decision to use Memorial Day as make-up day was made by administrators before the campaign in Iraq started, said Barbara Hunter, executive director of information and outreach. She said a few parents have complained, but added that while the school district respects their arguments, "I don't think there's any chance it will change." She said the schools could have a barbecue or similar event in celebration of troop efforts and many plan to talk to students about the significance of Memorial Day. "I suspect that many [students] miss the point of Memorial Day and don't realize how important what U.S. soldiers are doing is," Ms. Hunter said. "We're looking at this as really a way to teach them." Some teachers said they would rather tack on a school day at the end of the year than come to school on Memorial Day to meet the number of student-teacher contact days required. But Ms. Hunter said that wasn't done because students in grades seven through 12 are using those days to prepare for the Standards of Learning tests being held at the end of the school year. Kimberly Brooks, a speech pathologist at John Adams school, said she disagrees with the decision to have school that day but will try to educate students on the holiday by having them write letters, watch videos or discuss current events. "Even though I'm not a veteran, it's kind of deplorable because of where we live," Ms. Brooks said, referring to the school's proximity to the nation's capital and the Pentagon.
(Excerpt) Read more at washtimes.com ...
No, opinions can be wrong. For example, the position of some that sending children to public school is criminal child abuse is as wrong as those who hold the position that homeshcooling is criminal child abuse.
However, the question of public education admits many positions. So let us disagree.
You mean Armistice Day? To remember the signing of the treaty ending the 'War to end all Wars'?
In Illinois this is programed with a certain number of snow day already in the mix. This is more liberal anti-american crap.
The decision upset many teachers, several of whom are veterans or spouses of veterans, especially with service members fighting in Iraq.
"It's about people who give their lives for our country. This is about people in wheelchairs," said Hilari Hinnant, a first-grade teacher at John Adams Elementary School whose husband served in the Marine Corps during the Vietnam War.
"It's a serious holiday, especially given what our country has been through." Memorial Day is a day of remembrance for those who died in military service. Its roots are disputed, but it was first officially observed May 30, 1868, when flowers were placed on the graves of Union and Confederate soldiers at the Arlington National Cemetery.
Jacqualyne Evans Mcrae, a teacher at John Adams school, was part of an Air Force unit stationed in Aviano, Italy, during the 1991 Persian Gulf war, and the traditional holiday holds special meaning for her. But this Memorial Day, May 26, she will be working, while her counterparts in other area school districts will take time off to honor America's war dead. Ms. Evans Mcrae conceded that the day honoring troops may not be much more than a time to hit the pools and parks for some children, but added that the operations in Iraq make it more likely that parents would take the time this year to remind their children about the U.S.-led war efforts and the people involved in the same.
"There is the chance for a more open reflection and acknowledgment, and a lot of parents want their children to experience and know about it," she said. "I think more parents would go down to the memorials and monuments."
The decision to use Memorial Day as make-up day was made by administrators before the campaign in Iraq started, said Barbara Hunter, executive director of information and outreach. She said a few parents have complained, but added that while the school district respects their arguments, "I don't think there's any chance it will change." She said the schools could have a barbecue or similar event in celebration of troop efforts and many plan to talk to students about the significance of Memorial Day.
"I suspect that many [students] miss the point of Memorial Day and don't realize how important what U.S. soldiers are doing is," Ms. Hunter said. "We're looking at this as really a way to teach them." Some teachers said they would rather tack on a school day at the end of the year than come to school on Memorial Day to meet the number of student-teacher contact days required.
But Ms. Hunter said that wasn't done because students in grades seven through 12 are using those days to prepare for the Standards of Learning tests being held at the end of the school year.
Kimberly Brooks, a speech pathologist at John Adams school, said she disagrees with the decision to have school that day but will try to educate students on the holiday by having them write letters, watch videos or discuss current events.
"Even though I'm not a veteran, it's kind of deplorable because of where we live," Ms. Brooks said, referring to the school's proximity to the nation's capital and the Pentagon.
Now, the nagging question- is Memorial Day to remember ALL deceased, or just the deceased veterans?
There's the key. That darned public school accountability program advocated by President Bush.
I remember having to choose whether or not I would march with the Scouts or with the H.S. Marching Band. The parade ended in the town common, and there all marchers got free ice cream (although I suspect the boys in the VFW topped up with something a bit stronger).
And I remember standing in the cemeteries, listening to a silence broken only by a rifle salute, followed by Taps, and then a recital of "Flanders Field". This would have been in the '60's, when there were still numerous Great War veterans alive. How many kids know today why there are poppies sold on the street corners by the VFW? My kids do.
If that neighborhood is anything like mine, the parents had months in advance set up week-long trips, including non-refundable plane tickets, for that week. Cutting spring break by a day would get the School Board ousted.
When our schools have spring break, I don't schedule a Troop meeting for that week, and we don't have campouts either weekend; I'd be lucky if a third of the Troop showed up.
And then there are those legal immigrants who come to America for more than mere economic gain ... who do come to fully appreciate what they have been freely given, and manage to find a few hours out of the day to attend local Memorial Day observances, with a thankful heart.
They leave richer for the experience, and IMO make by far, the better citizen.
I wonder how they would like it (the next time there is some crisis overseas) for the military to tell them, "Hey .... sorry .... we are taking some time out to remember our fallen brothers in arms because you couldn't find the time to do it on the day that was set aside for it."
This dumbass principal or administrator needs to be told the saying on that gravestone of an American Soldier who lies on some small island out there in the Pacific Ocean ... it reads - I gave all of my tomorrows, just so you could have today.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.