Terrorism Eyed (In) Mysterious Death

AP | 2/16/02 | ALLEN G. BREED

[kattracks]

MEMPHIS, Tenn., Feb 16, 2002 (AP Online via COMTEX) -- Shortly before 1 a.m. last Sunday, witnesses saw flames erupt from the back seat of a 1992 Acura Legend as it crawled along a two-lane road skirting farm fields in the little Tennessee town of Piperton.

The driver breathed in the flames, her lungs searing, as the car veered off the road and came to rest against a utility pole near the Mississippi state line. There were no skid marks or furrows in the grass to indicate the driver had hit the brakes.

A witness rushed up and pulled open the car door, but the driver was not moving. She appeared to be already dead. When the first volunteer firefighters arrived, the car was engulfed in flames.

From the very beginning, it didn't look right, said Steve Kellett, chief of the Piperton Volunteer Fire Department.

The car had been moving too slowly for the accident to cause much damage. The wooden pole was barely dented. The radiator was pushed in a few inches, but the engine block was undamaged. Most important, the gas tank had not ruptured. The cardboard packaging for a replacement headlamp in the trunk was barely scorched.

What could have caused a fire so severe that it cooked the passenger compartment of the sedan down to the frame, burned the driver's arms and legs off, and left her charred beyond recognition? If someone had been trying to make this death look like an accident, they had done a lousy job.

Police began investigating the death as a homicide, though they have not ruled out suicide. The mystery deepened the next day when dental records identified the victim as Katherine Smith, 49, a state driver's license examiner.

Smith had been scheduled to be arraigned last Monday on federal charges of helping five Middle Eastern men from New York obtain fraudulent Tennessee driver's licenses.

One of the men, authorities say, drove from New York to Memphis on Sept. 11 - the day of the terrorist attack on the World Trade Center. And one of them, at the time of his arrest, was carrying in his wallet a pass to the trade center dated Sept. 5.

Was this a series of bizarre coincidences?

"The possibility of a really interesting story exists here," FBI Agent George W. Bolds said last week, brushing soot from his hands as he walked away from the charred vehicle impounded in a garage. Then again, he said, "it could turn out to be a whole lot less than people expect."

---

On the morning of Feb. 5, authorities say, a gray Dodge Durango and a white Toyota Avalon arrived in Memphis from New York and parked outside the motor vehicles office. Inside the cars sat six Middle Eastern men.

Tennessee is one of four states not requiring a Social Security number to get a license, and many people carry utility bills as proof of residence.

Perhaps the men saw Smith as she arrived in her blue blazer and gray slacks.

Shortly after she showed up for work, a man from the Toyota, Khaled Odtllah, a native of Jerusalem, joined the morning rush into the building. According to an FBI affidavit, he was clutching four signed driver's license applications.

Katherine Smith was a woman of modest means. She had a couple hundred dollars in a credit union account, a couple hundred more than that in checking, according to court records. She had a 1999 Ford Escort with a $10,000 lien and the Acura.

She and her daughter shared a one-story home in a rough-and-tumble neighborhood in the shadow of Memphis' Liberty Bowl stadium - a place where police warn outsiders not to be after dark. The neat little house is worth $65,000; Smith owed $55,000 on it.

She had worked for mental health agencies before joining the motor vehicle division in 1992. She was earning just over $23,000.

Neighbors say they hardly saw the woman because she was working all the time. After hours, she worked taking care of an elderly woman.

"She worked day and night," says Peola Wright, who lives two doors down. She called Smith a nice lady who sang in the church choir and tried to get neighbors to attend services.

The neighborhood is a few miles from where Khaled Odtllah lived, but it seems a world away.

According to records, Odtllah's last address was The Grove, a gated community in the Memphis suburb of Cordova, with swimming pools, tennis courts and spas. A sign out front boasts a first place award in 2000 for beautification.

Police say Odtllah came to the United States about 13 years ago from Jerusalem and had been in Tennessee for about 2 1-2 years.

Smith later told officials she met Odtllah at his gas station. He sold her the Acura, which was still in Odtllah's name when Smith died.

Somewhere along the line, police say, Smith and Odtllah became business partners.

As an examiner in an office processing 300 to 400 diver's license applicants each day, Smith screened applicants at a front counter and gave written and road tests.

On the applications Odtllah was carrying on Feb. 5, each man listed as his address 2840 Morning Lake Drive, in another gated community just outside Memphis. None of the men had checked the application's organ donor box.

At motor vehicles, the applications were approved and entered into the computer system. When Odtllah walked outside, the FBI was waiting for him.

Agents in New York had received a tip that the men would be traveling to Memphis that day, and the bureau's agents in Tennessee had staked out Smith's home and the motor vehicle office. When Odtllah and the others pulled out of the parking lot, agents flashed blue lights and pulled them over.

With Odtllah, police found Mostafa Said Abou-Shahi, Mohammed Fares, Sakher Hammad and his cousin Abdelmuhsen Mahmid Hammad. An unnamed juvenile was also taken into custody.

A few months ago, the contents of Sakher Hammad's wallet would have seemed innocuous: Two video rental cards; two major credit cards; a card designating him a "charter member" of Team Ford Racing; a New York plumber's business card.

And a pass, dated 09/05/01 that gave him access to the lower basement of One World Trade Center.

Shown a photocopy, New York City Port Authority officials said the pass looked authentic, but they couldn't be certain without seeing the original.

Authorities say Sakher Hammad told them he is plumber, and that he and his cousin were in the tower to work on the sprinkler system. New York authorities have no record of a plumber's license for either cousin.

A business card in Sakher Hammad's wallet was for a Magic Plumbing & Heating Inc. in Brooklyn. It advertises "custom kitchens, bathrooms, water heaters, boilers, repiping" - generally residential in nature.

A call to the business produced only a full voice-mailbox for someone named "Rocky." Using a reverse telephone directory, the AP found a list of phone numbers at the company's street address, all of them for individuals, among them Sakher Hammad.

Hammad's wallet also held courtesy cards from the New York City Patrolmen's Benevolent Association and the Detectives' Endowment Association of New York. The latter bears the inscription, "In memory of those who lost their lives on 9-11-01."

It is adorned with a fluttering American flag, a police badge and a picture of the twin towers.

When Smith was arrested, authorities say she admitted helping Odtllah obtain licenses for "cousins" on a half-dozen occasions in the past year. An FBI agent later testified that Odtllah was charging up to $1,200 each to help people get their new identities.

Authorities say the men arrested with Odtllah admitted being in the country illegally.

The day Smith was to appear in court, her car sat in an FBI garage in Memphis, the champagne finish bubbled and streaked with trails of melted rubber window stripping. The upholstery was burned away. Police couldn't even tell if Smith had been wearing a seat belt.

However, they had found a residue of gasoline on her body. The fire, the FBI determined, was intentionally set.

Bolds, the FBI agent, wondered how someone who was conscious could have stayed in the burning car. "If the car is on fire, you're going to stop in the middle of the highway if you have to, to get out," he said.

An autopsy is not yet finished.

On Wednesday, Abou-Shahi, Fares and Abdelmuhsen Hammad appeared in court wearing blue windbreakers provided by the court. They face charges of conspiring to obtain licenses with false information. Odtllah and Sakher Hammad had appeared in court Monday.

Court records indicate that another man, Omar Khayata, 20, had also applied for a license Feb. 5, using the same address. But he was not charged, and officials would not say whether he was the juvenile mentioned in the affidavit.

Lawyers for the defendants argued that their clients were being held only because of their ethnicity. "They seem to be trying to tie this to Sept. 11," said Clifton Harviel Jr., who represented Abou-Shahin.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Tim DiScenza replied that each man had participated in a conspiracy intended to acquire a "completely false and untraceable identity." Their motivation, he said, could be "further criminal activity."

In the wake of Sept. 11, there have been crackdowns on illegally obtained driver's licenses elsewhere. Several of the Sept. 11 hijackers had illegally obtained licenses in Virginia.

In denying bond for the five, federal magistrates cited the men's tenuous connections to the community and strong ties to other countries.

Court papers show Odtllah has a wife, a 2-year-old son, a mother and 10 siblings, all living in Jerusalem. Officials say he has "traveled extensively across the U.S. in the last few years."

A magistrate noted Sakher Hammad, "has no ties whatsoever to this community. He has substantial ties to Jordan or Gaza, where his mother lives. He has had less than stable employment ... and a cooperating witness has disappeared under suspicious circumstances."

Of the local telephone numbers listed on the license applications, three were out of service, and one was a fax.

When bond was denied, Fares put his head in his hands and wiped his eyes. The others showed no reaction.

---

Outside Smith's home, a row of red artificial flowers planted in the ground seems to wilt in the winter chill.

Family members have refused to talk. A wary elderly neighbor said, "I believe somebody killed her."

The answering machine message on Smith's phone was changed to provide information about her funeral Saturday. There was no wake, the message said, because wakes are for sadness and tears.

"Please wear lively attire," said a young woman's voice. "Because this is a joyous occasion - because she's going home to be with the Lord."

By ALLEN G. BREED

Copyright 2002 Associated Press, All rights reserved

[weegee]

I recall reading that they do have a record of licenses she processed and are investingating her handiwork for other possible instances of fraud.

These licenses were supposed to be "untraceable" (the names and addresses wouldn't match any real data associated with these men). They may know which IDs are "fake" but it may not offer them much security in apprehending these men (except for the photos).

[Lion's Cub]

I'm wondering if the AP is trying to hide here. This article doesn't square with the others I've read.

I've noticed a switch in the time line to place the murder around 1AM. But news reports in the first few days place it 45 minutes earlier. Maybe the 1AM time just comes from the time that the FBI arrived on the scene. But could there be another reason to establish the murder as occuring 45 minutes later than it really happened?

But there are more significant differences. According to this story, she was 200 yards from the border, heading NW on 72. JMJ333 can tell us for sure, but that doesn't look on the map like the little country lane that the article implies.

The implication that the car was crawling doesn't fit, either. According to this article , the car had to cross a ditch to get to the pole. And this article mentions the pole was broken.

The AP claims that A witness rushed up and pulled open the car door, but the driver was not moving. She appeared to be already dead. Yet this article describes all the trouble the firemen had getting the blaze out. So how did the witness manage to open the car door?

[Lion's Cub]

Oops. Should be: I'm wondering if the AP is trying to hide something here.

[Inge_CAV]

BTTT!

[EODGUY]

Ironically, I watched a news blurb last night about all the pro-jihad fund raisers that have been and continue to be hosted in our country. Tampa, Atlanta, Cleveland and Chicago were some of the cities mentioned.

IMO labels are nothing but a substitute for a non-existent argument, so folks can label me in whatever manner they feel necessary. My point is that we have an immigration system that is ineffective and totally unworkable. Based on our knowledge of the terrorist members, we must begin deportation proceedings yesterday and dedicate our law enforcement community to rooting out terrorist sects in our country.

After a new system has been developed, tested and put in place, people can begin applying for visas to our country.

I can't believe that there is any other country in the world that would turn a blind eye to those in that country who are trying to destroy the country from within.

[zog]

--you've pretty much described my personal reason for wanting to "end decades of abuse". Way too much weird crap goes on in the highest political/economic levels to assure me in any way that our various "leaders" elected or self elected in business are always 100% pure "patriotic". The opposite (generally speakig) seems more likely to me.. The obvious on purpose destruction of the middle class is the biggest clue, the next are all the under- and-falsely- reported and never really "solved completely" scandals that arise.

[Lion's Cub]

I just came across FBI checking 5 in illegal-license cases for possible al-Qaida links.

An off-duty Mississippi police officer driving in the opposite direction saw her back seat on fire at 12:45 a.m. Sunday. By the time he doubled back, she had veered off the road and tapped a utility pole before her car burst into a fireball.

I remembered something about FBI agent Nash testifying that there 6 unnamed witnesses (all related). When I checked the story here, I see Nash testified that those witnesses all said it happened about 12:45, too.

[piasa]

fyi

[JMJ333]

Memphis has a large Moslem community--including a branch of Nation of Islam. Maybe this is the way Smith is tied to the Suspects?

Ever seen Steven Emerson's Jihad in America?"

[EODGUY]

Ms. Smith's actions disgust me, regardless of her motivation, but I must admit people who are traitors and career military personnel truly boggle my mind.

I read recently that an USAF enlisted man was just exposed as a traitor.

I was held to a higher standard when I was in the military and I think that should be true today. I also believe that 99.9% of all active military personnel are our most patriotic citizens and deserve to be treated and paid as such.

[VOA]

The question is, did the sprinkler system in the WTC work on 9/11?

Or if these (possible) terrorists were hoping to make them spray something other
than water on 9-11.

Wouldn't it be a hoot to find out that these guys were part of a terrorist group,
totally separate from Al-Quida, that had intended to spray something like nerve
gas via the WTC sprinkler system...but 9-11 happened before they could carry out their mission?

[Inge_CAV]

"An off-duty Mississippi police officer driving in the opposite direction saw her back seat on fire at 12:45 a.m. Sunday. By the time he doubled back, she had veered off the road and tapped a utility pole before her car burst into a fireball."

If anyone had thrown a flammable substance into the back seat of her vehicle while she was driving there is a good chance this officer would have noticed it.

[Registered]

It was obviously set on fire with the victim in the driver's seat and rolled at such a low speeed that the murderer could jump safely out.

[denydenydeny]

Cross-indexing.

[Inge_CAV]

That would be to difficult to do and keep from being seen by other motorists. This stretch of Hwy is rural but has lots of traffic.

[Inge_CAV]

Many years ago I was stopped at a roadblock very near where this crash occurred. I had to pay a $10.00 fine in Cash, on the spot, to leave. You don't forget things like that or where it happened.

: )

[JMJ333]

Mourners remember the good deeds of license examiner, not how she died

By Clay Bailey
bailey@gomemphis.com

Mourners filled the Family Funeral Care chapel Saturday to talk about the good deeds and Christian life of Katherine Smith, balancing the publicity surrounding her fiery death last week and the charge that she sold fraudulent driver's licenses.

About 175 people created a standing-room-only arrangement in the chapel, at times swaying and singing along with hymns and testimonials.

"We're not here to remember how she died," said Rev. L. F. Self of Great Ebenezer Baptist Church. "She requested a lively funeral. . . . We came to remember how she lived."

Smith, a 49-year-old state driver's license examiner, was found burned to death in a 1992 Acura Legend after it veered off U.S. 72 in Fayette County in the early morning hours of Feb. 10. Authorities said she died from inhaling the flames from a fire started with the help of an accelerant.

There are questions about connections between her death and federal charges of fraudulently obtaining a Tennessee driver's license against her and five co-defendants. Smith was accused of conspiring to illegally provide licenses to the five men, some of whom were in the country illegally.

The six were arrested Feb. 5 at the testing center on Summer after the transaction. Smith, an examiner for nine years, was released on her own recognizance and was to appear in federal court the day after the discovery of her body alongside the highway.

Smith's family members declined to talk to the media Saturday either at the funeral home or burial at Memphis Memory Gardens. And there were few references to the matter during the 45-minute service.

"While others are speculating or wondering about what's in the background . . . I know how she lived," Self said. "She was a child of God."

Among those attending the service were a group of state driver's license examiners in their uniforms.

Mourners began arriving more than an hour before the 11 a.m. service in the chapel at 4925 Summer. There were hugs and well wishes to friends and family.

Near the start all the pews were full, and an extra room in the back of the chapel quickly turned into an overflow of people standing against the wall.

There were hymns and poems, Scripture readings and acknowledgments for the well wishes shown to the family.

While the mood at times was somber, there also were moments when it seemed like a celebration. A solo brought the crowd to a hand-waving, clapping display of joy with hallelujahs and amens added for verbal support.

Self, decked in a red sports coat, took swigs of bottled water and wiped his brow as he recalled how Smith helped take care of sick family members and her involvement in the church. He said when he preached a sermon several weeks ago about how this year should be better than 2001, he had no idea he would deal with Smith's death.

"Little did I know that in 2002, we were going to lose our best member," Self said. ". . . Little did I know we would lose a precious stone like (Smith). "There's so much speculation, so much mysticism and mystery surrounding the death of our sister, but there is no mystery of how she lived."

No mystery how she lived??? Best member? This stuff gets weirder by the day.

[JMJ333]

It indeed must have been a long time ago, because Piperton has grown a lot in the last 10 years, just like Collierville. Everyone keeps moving farther and farther East trying to escape city taxes.

[Inge_CAV]

Yes, that happened several years ago and Collierville has really grown from the small town it was back then.