Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: Asmodeus
"Nearly 5 1/2 years have now gone by since the Flight 800 disaster. Yet, not one expert witness report analyst has ever agreed with Commander Donaldson's allegations about the observations of the witnesses. Not even one."

As you have pointed out, the FBI 302 reports are totally inaccurate representations of what the eyewitnesses told the FBI agents who questioned them. Why do you think ANY "witness report analyst" could gain any knowledge at all from a report written from flawed, and in some cases, bogus 302s?

The fact is that the only " expert witness report analyst"s that have analyzed the reports are FBI analysts who would be unlikely to undermine their employers assertions. The NTSB "eyewitness" group was disbanded after the FBI made it plain they were not to talk to the eyewitnesses and were required to rely on the 302s.

You have a one note criticism of Commander Donaldson's theories based on your flawed analysis of when and where in the timeline of various witnesses they reported the "big boom"... on this you ignore every other piece of evidence.

You challenge people to fit eyewitness reports into the big boom... but those very reports are taken from the flawed 302s. GARBAGE IN, GARBAGE OUT... especially if the garbage was manufactured to fit one scenario, the official one.

Asmodeus, if it wasn't a missile, WHAT do you claim brought down TWQ-800? The Center Wing Tank spontaneously exploding? The cargo door hatch scenario? Meteor? Spit?

17 posted on 12/20/2001 10:31:17 PM PST by Swordmaker
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]


To: Swordmaker
"As you have pointed out, the FBI 302 reports are totally inaccurate representations of what the eyewitnesses told the FBI agents who questioned them. Why do you think ANY "witness report analyst" could gain any knowledge at all from a report written from flawed, and in some cases, bogus 302s?"

302 reports may or may not be accurate representations of some things said by those interviewed but they are never complete or reliable, are not "witness reports" and are not evidence of what was said or wasnt said.

You did not support your allegation that some of the FBI's 302's are bogus with any evidence or reference source URL's. Can you? If so, please extend the readers the courtesy of doing so.

"The fact is that the only "expert witness report analyst"s that have analyzed the reports are FBI analysts who would be unlikely to undermine their employers assertions."

Not so. Click here.

"You challenge people to fit eyewitness reports into the big boom... but those very reports are taken from the flawed 302s. GARBAGE IN, GARBAGE OUT... especially if the garbage was manufactured to fit one scenario, the official one."

The "big boom" Massive Fireball explosion was by far the most dramatic of the rapid fire sequence of fiery events in the sky and it was seen by virtually all of the witnesses including those who did not see the immediately preceding fiery streak. Expert witness interviewers know the importance of getting oriented to where and when the major events took place. Others don't. But Kallstrom succumbed at the outset to his knee jerk reaction that zoom+boom=missile shootdown and on that basis alone sought and got authority from Louis Freeh, Janet Reno and the White House to conduct a criminal investigation of the disaster and seize control from the NTSB, thereafter wasting the better part of $40,000,000 in his wild goose chase.

The tinfoil hatters had the same knee jerk reaction that zoom+boom=missile shootdown as dramatized by the graphics they came up with, such as the following that appeared in most if not all of their websites in which the unmistakable "big boom" Massive Fireball explosion immediately follows the fiery streak.

The "Zoom+Boom=Missile Shootdown" Fantasy

Please extend the readers the courtesy of quoting from The "Missile Witnesses" Myth what you relied on for your allegation that it was based on FBI 302 reports.

19 posted on 12/21/2001 10:20:12 AM PST by Asmodeus
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 17 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson