[pcl]

At what point should we not be free to make a choice, and who, other than God, is to say that we are not?

Once again, your question is divisive and does merit an answer.

[MitchellC]

At what point should we not be free to make a choice, and who, other than God, is to say that we are not?

Once again, your question is divisive and does merit an answer.

You're right, like all good questions it's divisive - it's sure to make clear the moral absolutists and the moral relativists, for one.

You're also right that it merits an answer (though you probably forgot a "not" in a rush to get away from it).

Again, at what point do we, as a body of individuals, say 'we cannot ethically allow one person to do this to another'? That's neither vague nor stupid - it's a question of the government's rightful role in our lives, so don't try to condescendingly side-step the question.

If you don't have an answer or have never even considered it, then just admit it.