Posted on 12/26/2023 5:52:00 PM PST by SeekAndFind
Should be any any usa voter!
If an American cannot question a person’s status running for president .. then SCOTUS is useless!☹️
Subject to its jurisdiction
Means someone who is a citizen
Someone who is not a citizen annoy give birth to a baby that is suddenly a citizen
No one here illegally has ever given birth to a citizen regardless of how badly that has been interpreted
There is no such thing as a birther
Just illegals according to the constitution
Marjorie Taylor Greene Blasts Possible Trump Campaign Hire Loomer—Calls Her ‘Unstable And A Documented Liar’
Constitutional law doesn’t seem to be her strong suit.
You are correct
unexceptionable, the viewpoint that:
“natural-born citizens are those born in the country of parents who are citizens” (Scott v. Sandford, 1856)
In Minor v. Happersett (1875), the Supreme Court defined two classes of persons. The first class consists of children born in the United States, of U.S.-citizen parents. The second class consists of all other U.S.-born children, regardless of their parents’ citizenship. The Court used the term “natural born citizen” only in reference to members of the first class. Regarding members of the second class, the Court doubted they were even citizens, let alone natural born citizens. In the Court’s opinion, natural born citizens are “distinguished from” aliens or foreigners, suggesting that a natural born citizen is someone who is not a “foreigner” (foreign citizen) at birth [05].
Whose responsibility is it to enforce presidential eligibility?
Let's say Nikki wins the GOP nomination, long shot as that may be, could an individual state secretary leave her off the ballot because this secretary doesn't believe she's eligible?
It would likely take this to happen first before SCOTUS would even look at the matter.
😀😆🤣
She’s right. Nimratta is not eligible.
Selectively reading bits and pieces of the law is not how the law as a whole works. Haley is a natural born citizen. People on the political right need to get over using NBC arguments when they do not apply.
The only question is — WHO HAS THE STANDING TO BRING IT BEFORE THE SUPREME COURT???
??
If Nikki gets the nomination every Democrat will have standing
“The Founders after establishing a country did not want a future President who may have been born here from a foreigner , to be eligible for President.”
Exactly. It’s all about where a person’s loyalty lies.
RE: Haley is a natural born citizen.
I’d like to read your reasoning regarding how she qualifies.
Happy New Year SF!
Natural Born has nothing to do with a “citizenship status.” If you have to ascertain a status you are not natural born, i.e. born two citizen parents within the physical jurisdiction of your country.
Now, let the people who can’t understand Supreme Court Decisions or comprehend the Federalist Papers etc have the floor.
Thank you. Happy New Year!
I’m having post-Christmas nachos tonight
But not from the gas station ⛽⛽⛽
She may lose, but why? Where’s your argument?
I was surprised that Joe DeGenova and Victoria Toensing are pushing Haley for VP on grounds the ticket would more easily win. But they didn’t say how replacing one disloyal VP with another would improve things.
We went through this with Obama, who also was not qualified. You will not get an argument. Here’s an important point though- If Haley really cared about the Constitution and rule of law, why would she run at all?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.