Posted on 09/15/2023 7:22:00 PM PDT by DoodleBob
There are a lot of comments here about failures in weather forecasting. My perspective is this- Weather is inherently chaotic, and our understanding is limited.
Therefore ren I am constantly amazed by our ability to provide the forecasts we do receive, and how we are able to identify where dangerous weather will strike as oftens as we do.
Meteorologists now make the nearly impossible look easy, then we thank them by complain about when they do get it wrong.
Top men know these things.
Top men.
Actually I think it is, and the answer is that the underlying physics is so chaotice we cannot predict climate since we cannot even predict weather 2 weeks out.
Emanuael and the late Doug Lilly of NCAR and his ilk espoused this stuff for at least four decades now. Then it was preached that deterministic forecast had a valid range of a few days or less, and there was little hope for improvement.
The main problem, other than the governing equations being nonlinear, is an incomplete and less-than accurate description of the initial conditions. This is due to measurement errors and a sparsity of measurements in time and space with wide gaps through the earth’s atmosphere. It is my opinion that the choice of emphasizing satellite technology rather than ground-based technologies have slowed our advancement in achieving a better initial condition.
We are in Ellsworth, Maine and expect high winds and rain.
The amount of rain and velocity of the winds in the forecasts have changed every couple of hours: the last forecast much less rain and wind speed less than predicted.
We were worried about the 60- 70 mph gusts.
Hmmph!!! Must be intentional misinformation.
The entire world knows that Al Gore can predict the weather at least 20 years out
And “Grating Greta” Thunberg can beat tha!.
/s
I don’t see much accuracy two weeks out.
As a friend of mine said, they can’t get yesterday’s forecast right.
I’ve seen your posts before. I am visiting daughter’s family in Whiting. I lived in Roque Bluffs for 18 years before vacating to Florida. I am a retired AF weather officer and engineer so I check many weather sites. For this storm I found Carabu weather forecasting much lower winds than AccuWeather. I chech BarHarbor and Ellsworth observations. As a mariner, I am not, you know what to look for.
Larry
The NOAA seems to take the safe approach, which is to almost always predict warmer to much warmer than normal (which only goes back about 150 years) for the NE. Predictions last Spring:
https://web.archive.org/web/20230511102349im_/https://www.cpc.ncep.noaa.gov/products/predictions/long_range/lead01/off01_temp.gif
https://web.archive.org/web/20230511102349im_/https://www.cpc.ncep.noaa.gov/products/predictions/long_range/lead01/off01_prcp.gif
In reality: Last year at this time, we were smack dab in the middle of a drought. This summer, we are challenging the all-time seasonal rainfall records in Boston and Worcester. By this date last summer, Boston had 19 days of 90 degrees or higher including a 6-day and 7-day heatwave. This summer, the city has reached 90 just 4 times. - https://www.cbsnews.com/boston/news/boston-summer-temperatures-90s-climate-change-weather/
Northeast's hottest weather of summer may come in early September ....for the summer season as a whole, temperatures in many areas during the three-month period from June 1 to Aug. 31, cumulative temperatures are finishing within 1 degree of the historical average and rainfall has ended up near the historical average.
A notable exception is in New England where summer rainfall was nearly two times that of the historical average, thanks in large part to excessive rain in July. - https://www.accuweather.com/en/weather-forecasts/northeasts-hottest-weather-of-summer-may-come-in-early-september/1575776 Composite from above: past and present NOAA predictions:
Right, they can’t forecast 2 weeks out but demand BILLIONS to ‘fix’ the climate?????
Science.
Weather forecasts aren’t even accurate 24 hours out. Last Sunday, my husband wanted to do an outside project and asked me what the weather was going to be like for the upcoming week. I told him practically no chance of rain according to the forecast. It rained on each and every day.
I’m with you.
I remember vividly, in the 70s, getting rained in when tomorrow’s forecast was for sunshine. Or packing an umbrella and then getting sunshine. Very often.
The accuracy of the 24-48 hour forecast over the past few decades is an unsung benefit of the proper application of science and statistical/numeric forecasting methods. Parenthetically, 1 out of every 4 meteorologists came out of Penn State since the 1980s, and as a Nittany Lion I approve of this message.
The problems have come from these new forecasting godz, who believe their own hype, and go out 5 days or two weeks. It’s like someone getting the gold in the 100-yard dash now thinking he can win the NY Marathon. I ignore those forecasts except to monitor for general trends - and even then it’s a coin toss at best.
Then there’s global warming or cooling or whatever they’re pushing nowadays. These wizards sniff at us little people, “weather isn’t climate.” Maybe. But a vital element in ANY data-driven exercise is consistency and homogeneity in data collection and quality. The improvements in 24-48-hour forecasts are as much a function of good data as it is better techniques. But the temperature and flood etc data from 1979 on backward was collected with little focus in consistency, or accuracy….in fact I bet the margin of error in the old thermometers is within the 1-degree C “rise” in global temperatures they thrust upon is.
Therefore, I applaud meteorologists as they execute their day-to-day job of forecasting tomorrow. There is great value in that activity. But please, you’re a plumber: stop trying to lord over the sewer system.
Here in GA its hardly accurate for one week.
But the socialist know to 1/2 degree the temperature 100 years in the future.
I look at the weather forecast at night and the next day and the rest of the week I see the forecast constantly changing. They cannot get 1 day accurate.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.