Posted on 08/01/2023 5:37:17 AM PDT by jacknhoo
‘This belongs in the Smithsonian’: Inside the meme video operation that swallowed Ron DeSantis’ campaign
THE SCOOP
Senior aides to Ron DeSantis oversaw the campaign’s high-risk strategy of laundering incendiary videos produced by their staff through allied anonymous Twitter accounts, a set of internal campaign communications obtained by Semafor reveals.
The videos include two that have created recurring distractions for his campaign in recent weeks: an anti-Trump video that featured a fascist symbol, and another that attacked Donald Trump for past comments supportive of LGBT rights.
The meme-filled videos emerged from a Signal channel called “War Room Creative Ideas,” screenshots of which were shared with Semafor and whose authenticity was confirmed by a second source familiar with the campaign. The chat in Signal, an encrypted messaging app, offers the first clear look into the “war room” that has defined the Florida governor’s candidacy, and is presided over by his high-profile and confrontational director of rapid response, Christina Pushaw. The correspondence obtained by Semafor also offers a glimpse of a strategy that mixes digital aggression and (unsuccessful) attempts to keep the campaign’s own activities secret. The messages were set to disappear after one week.
Screenshots of the “War Room” chat reviewed by Semafor included staffers praising a widely-derided and since-deleted video — originally posted on an anonymous account, “Ron DeSantis Fancams” — that included a version of the Sonnenrad, a symbol associated with Nazi Germany.
“This belongs in the Smithsonian,” wrote Kyle Lamb, the campaign’s director of research and data, before the video blew up in the campaign’s face. He was among the 38 staffers laid off in recent weeks amid a campaign “reset.”
Messages viewed by Semafor also show members of the War Room group actively sharing images to put in the video while it was in the editing process, though not the Sonnenrad symbol that was in the final version.
Pushaw used the Signal group to spread content to anonymous allies, the chat shows. She told junior staffers that they should keep making meme videos, while other aides also said they wanted to push out more videos, according to the person familiar with the campaign. The chat included other senior staffers among its dozen-plus members, including press secretary Bryan Griffin.
The “War Room” chat was also used to place more conventional opposition research with accounts on Twitter (which has since been renamed “X”). In one July 19 exchange viewed by Semafor, Pushaw shared a “fun” clip of Trump talking about China at a Fox News town hall. She asked the Signal group if anyone knew “any Anons who might want it,” adding that “if we post it or a named influencer posts it, it might get noted.”
Another staffer soon replied that they could send the video to “proud elephant,” referring to a Twitter account that has pushed out various pieces of pro-DeSantis content, including the anti-LGBT video that mixed clips of DeSantis with images from the film “American Psycho” and the “GigaChad,” a meme of a photoshopped bodybuilder.
The ProudElephantUS account had just shared another China-related clip from the same event, leading the War Room chat member to think that “he might be interested.” The campaign has never publicly confirmed or denied ownership over the LGBT and Sonnenrad videos, which staffers retweeted after they were posted by the anonymous accounts. They recently fired one aide, Nate Hochman, who shared the latter video and, according to an Axios report, created it.
The New York Times reported that the anti-LGBT video was also produced within the campaign. The creator of that video remains on staff, and the content was approved by senior staffers before being sent out, according to the person familiar with the campaign. The chat was shut down after the video featuring the Sonnenrad caused a national media firestorm, and an image of members being removed from the group was reviewed by Semafor.
The DeSantis campaign declined to answer questions about their staff’s role in overseeing the videos and whether DeSantis had directed any changes in the campaign in response to the subsequent firestorm around them.
In a Monday interview with Fox News, DeSantis defended the premise of the anti-LGBT video posted by ProudElephantUS, saying it was based on legitimate criticisms of Trump’s record.
“These things get shared, or whatever — and look, I’m responsible for it. Don’t get me wrong,” DeSantis said. “But the idea that I was sitting there, like — oh, share this video? No. It’s a rapid response thing.”
DAVE AND SHELBY'S VIEW
The Signal group offers a rare look at how DeSantis’ campaign sought to fight a meme war — and how its embrace of a rowdy corner of Twitter helped throw his campaign off track. They also make clear the videos were not the result of an individual staffer or two striking out on their own, but something that was embedded in the campaign’s operations, which are more chaotic than DeSantis’ image as a buttoned-down administrator might suggest.
The news comes as the “War Room,” and Pushaw in particular, have been under special scrutiny amid complaints from inside and outside the campaign that its message has been too erratic and focused on esoteric online fights that distract from the candidate’s own message. The Signal group suggests that other top DeSantis aides were, at minimum, looped in on her work with the “War Room.”
Pushaw recently drew attention by escalating what turned out to be a massive fight that roped in several prominent Black Republicans after she attacked Rep. Byron Donalds, R-Fla. over his heavily qualified criticism of Florida’s proposed education standards on slavery. She compared him to Vice President Kamala Harris.
In a separate political brawl, Pushaw tweeted over the weekend that Trump’s campaign had “scammed” donors to fund his legal fees, seemingly going further than DeSantis’ own attacks. When a Politico reporter asked DeSantis about the Pushaw comment on Monday after a speech on his new economic plan, he said he was “not familiar” with what she had said.
“At the end of the day, you know, we’re here to talk about restoring this economy,” DeSantis said. “If you ask voters, are they more interested in hearing about that, or the process stories about politics, I think that they want to hear about the country’s future.”
ROOM FOR DISAGREEMENT DeSantis has pushed back on the idea that his campaign is “too online,” saying that the “War Room” operation has a role in fighting off detractors on social media, but is not reflective of his broader message to the average voter.
“I think that there’s a place for that,” he told Megyn Kelly on her podcast last week. “But ultimately, the people in Iowa and New Hampshire, they’re not following the latest Twitter war. They’re following what’s going on in their lives, and I’m very cognizant of that.”
The reporter in this article was given access to reviewing Team DeSantis "War Room" encrypted chats on Signal.
Pushaw is mentioned frequently in the article.
“Pushaw is mentioned frequently in the article.”
People who think DeSantis dropped out of heaven to save humanity may want to get to know Christina Pushaw a bit better. Basically makes Hillary look like minor league stuff.
This is funny in so many ways. Earlier today, Ed Rollins told the Hill “it’s not the campaign’s fault,” that DeSoros was “a very flawed candidate” (true). But that’s spoken like a campaign consultant.
In May, Rollins had said DeSantis “will be our next president,” and now he says he would be “shocked” if Trump didn’t win.
So we have 1) It’s the campaign’s fault; 2) DeSoros is a “flawed candidate,” or my take 3) There were overwhelming structural issues that the DeSoros campaign couldn’t begin to overcome, namely that Trump was an incumbent, essentially; that Trump had saved DeSoros in 2018 (and now he’s lying about it); that DeSoros had to start not only from a position of DISLOYALTY but also DISHONESTY by saying he hadn’t decided whether he was going to run.
Voters see that, and they don’t like either of those qualities.
Wow, didn’t know about her. Looks like a first class nut.
Pushaw is the only American that I know of who was at Zelensky’s Victory Party when he was ‘elected’ a few years ago. And that was after causing a war in Georgia.
I don’t think attacking Trump will help DeSanctus get traction with MAFA voters.
Sure, Low-T anti-Trumpers will cheer and toast their soy lattes. But Rob has their votes already.
Trump has transmogrified into a symbol that galvanizes MAGA voters. - he has ascended to the embodiment on MAGA to his voters.
People do not like you to attack their symbols. In fact, it makes them hate you.
By attacking Trump, DeSanctus is attacking Making America Great Again, and Trump’s supporters.
If anything, resorting to this type of subterfuge screams that few want DeSanctis on his merits - and his message falls on deaf ears as a Presidential message.
Rob jumped the shark a while back. His show won’t be renewed for a new season. He just doesn’t understand what happened yet.
My 2 cents.
Moreover, with the GOP electorate loyal to Trump, DeSantis cannot hope to beat him. The best that DeSantis can do is to establish himself as the preferred, most Trump-like alternative if Trump himself is taken out by the Biden administration's legal attacks. In effect, DeSantis and other GOP candidates have to position themselves like potential suitors to a highly attractive prospective widow with an ailing husband. As they hover about, they have to act as if they hope the husband pulls through while consistently being their charming best in case he does not.
In short, DeSantis and his B-list campaign team simply do not recognize that he has to carefully woo the GOP electorate without doing anything to contradict their affection and loyalty to Trump.
+++++++++++++
I bet you don't get paid big dollars as being a campaign advisor. You certainly are much more astute than the douches that are currently running the governors ship into the proverbial iceberg.
It's not that difficult. Don't be an ingrate acting like the 2018 FLA governor endorsement was insignificant. Nobody likes an ingrate.
more interested in hearing about economy, or the process stories about politics
The story I hear is that the campaign wanted to have it both ways...and it backfired.
One thing to campaigns need to consider...inevitably a campaign that hires too many staff too early. Inevitably some of those staff will leave (for whatever reason) and they will tell stories about what happens on the inside.
Either don’t go fat early...or make sure your campaign doesnt create its own distractions. This latter is near impossible in a good campaign...so consider the don’t go fat early path.
Needing a department to create memes reeks of desperation.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.