Posted on 07/15/2022 11:00:39 AM PDT by Former Proud Canadian
Vaccinated people are now more likely to be hospitalized or die from Covid, even after adjusting for fact they're older than the unvaccinated, according to official government estimates from the Canadian province of Manitoba.
In May, the most recent month for which figures are available, only 9 percent of Covid deaths and 14 percent of hospital admissions in Manitoba occurred among unvaccinated people, even though they are 17 percent of the population.
Manitoba, which has about 1.4 million residents, also provides figures that are adjusted for the fact that vaccinated and boosted people tend to be older.
Those show that in May, vaccinated but unboosted people were about 50 percent more likely to be hospitalized or die of Covid than unvaccinated people. People who had received boosters had roughly the same risk of hospitalization or death as the unvaccinated.
(Excerpt) Read more at alexberenson.substack.com ...
According to the bar graphs Harrison grabbed from the Manitoba site, severe outcomes were lowest for the boosted and highest for the fully vaccinated in: Figure 6. Age-Standardized Rate (/100,000 person days) and Risk of Severe Outcomes Associated with COVID-19 Manitoba, May 1, 2022 – May 31, 2022
But if you look at the previous month, April 1, 2022 – April 30, 2022, ICU admissions are much higher in the unvaccinated and lowest in the boosted, and the death rate for the unvaccinated is way higher, lowest again in the boosted:
Web page:
https://www.gov.mb.ca/health/publichealth/surveillance/covid-19/2022/week_26/index.html
Similar in the month before that, March 1, 2022 – March 31, 2022, when hospital admissions were slightly higher for the fully vaccinated vs unvaccinated and much lower in the boosted; ICU admissions were higher for the unvaccinated and lowest in the bloosted,; death rate for unvaccinated highest by far, lowest for the boosted:
Web page:
https://www.gov.mb.ca/health/publichealth/surveillance/covid-19/2022/week_20/index.html
So why is May different from the previous months? Given how small are the numbers of hospitalizations, ICU admissions and deaths, it could easily be just a statistical hiccup. We can’t check it, as the numbers given for hospitilazation, ICU admission and death by age group are cumulative, beginning December 16, 2020. The page does not show the actual numbers by month to compare to the graph.
The total population of Manitoba is only 1,342,000. So, when you’re looking at a death rate risk of about 0.15 per 100,000 for the unvaccinated and boosted in May, that’s only 2 deaths in each group in all of Manitoba. And then there’s the death rate risk for the fully vaccinated of about 0.24 per 100,000, or 3.2 deaths. Add in the age standardization formula used on top of the low raw numbers, and, really how statistically relevant are any of these graphs? The confidence level must be pathetic.
Trust Berenson to choose this oddball graph as “proof” of his pet theory. smh
Well, the old folks in the nursing home automatically got vaccinated, so ... even the ones without dementia didn’t get a choice to think no about it.
Friend in his early 70s, big believer in vax, had a heart-attack about 2 months after his first mRNA booster. Doctor is suggesting its time for he and his wife get a 2nd booster. Suddenly he isn’t so sure. He was lucky to survive it.
The study adjusted for that. Needle kneelers just went right along after seeing so very many test positive and experience flu symptoms at the worst. They believed the lie that there were millions positive with no symptoms.
After decades in the lab every one will tell you, correlations with symptoms are evidence their test system is accurate. Pcr targets set by who?
And we were using single target positives, probably still are. That a not just no for pcr testing. Multiple targets are standard because pcr tests have a higher false positive rate.
Any solution the government, particularly global governments are pushing is suspect from the word go.
Kneel once and they will never allow you to rise again.
See #41. These graphs are meaningless. Manitoba has a small population. Only 2 or 3 deaths in each of the three groups. You simply cannot get any meaningful statistical analysis out of such tiny numbers.
If three obese unvaccinated people with diabetes died during a month, but only two fully vaccinated people with no risky underlying health conditions died, the graph would reverse. How would you like that? (BTW, there is no adjustment for those with/without comorbidities.) As those with such underlying health conditions are more likely to be vaccinated, such a scenario would be somewhat unlikely but entirely possible — we are talking very small numbers here where only one death death flips the chart.
As you can see, in previous months the charts showed the unvaccinated as having the highest risk for serious outcomes. The actual numbers involved are still very small, though, and I don’t think they can get anything statistically meaningful out them, either.
Yes. They weren’t allowed to leave and had food delivered. Worst of all, everyone seemed to know someone who died from Covid.
just a statistical hiccup....................... We can’t check it,
\/
That’s your ‘ debunk ‘ ?
Bwa ha ha ha.
Shall we play a game once more?
????
Can you be ANY more creepy, dugwaybiolab?
Sounds like something a deranged character, from an evil novel/movie would say.
You've out-eviled yourself, 9-5, $hift Working $hot $hill.
dugwayduke... come out and play...
Jane Long wrote: “Can you be ANY more creepy, dugwaybiolab Sounds like something a deranged character, from an evil novel/movie would say.”
Q: “Shall we play a game once more?”
https://freerepublic.com/focus/bloggers/4073774/posts
📂
Just like everything else, things are opposite in Canada. EH Hoser. You got a problem with it Eh?
you play games every time you post...
You are one obsessed $hill bot.
For someone who repeatedly invokes Q, to mock FReepers who’ve chosen NOT to take, or dare question these horrid, not safe/not effective $hots…..you post that??
Again….you have outdone your bot, $W$$ self.
It certainly does.
” government estimates from the Canadian province of Manitoba.”
If the Metis die off who will make the Pemmican?
Jane Long wrote: “For someone who repeatedly invokes Q, to mock FReepers who’ve chosen NOT to take, or dare question these horrid, not safe/not effective $hots…..you post that??”
If you continue to accuse Q of being a ‘creepy, deranged character from an evil novel/movie” the other QTards are going to take your magic decoder ring.
Lame.
Just like your $hift working $hot $hilling, troll.
When is clock out, today, 9-5 bot?
You’re right I forgot about that. All the nursing home residents had no choice.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
