Skip to comments.Decision Against Mask Mandates on Aircraft , US District Judge Kathryn Kimball Mizelle, Link to Opinion
Posted on 04/20/2022 7:12:53 AM PDT by Candor7
Judge has been attacked in the media and on television by the left. The propaganda on the MSM is piling up pretty high. As matter of fact the good judge is being publicly denegrated because of her correct ruling n the issue pursuant to the Constitution of The United States.She is also denegrated becasue she is a Trump appointee. So be informed. Her opinion in the case is excellent and well worth the read. Biden will lose his Appeal in all liklihood, but Biden still wants the power to coontrol the People through masking, whichi anyone is free to do, but mandating mask wearing is not even supported by science, Browse the CDC site, you won't see any science supporting mask mandates because masks to not prevent viral infectionsm and because the fact is that it increases CO2 iin the blood, and can be very bad for you.
The power to mandate health rules and mandates are essentially relegated to the states. Thats a fact.The feds have no authority in that field .
And the decison is spot on, you can read it in full at the link : [ https://cases.justia.com/federal/district-courts/florida/flmdce/8:2021cv01693/391798/53/0.pdf?ts=1650371569 ]
Ping to written decision of US District Judge Kathryn Kimball Mizelle, a brilliant Trump appointee.
No more masks on ‘de planez!’
The judges that should be ostracized are the commie judges and the FISA judges who okayed the Trump spying. By the way, who were they?
You are right, we need a list of them, where they work and their home addresses.
Should not be to hard. Its public information now.
The opinion is spot on. It is especially strong in those areas that the government is likely to base an appeal on. The definition of sanitation as found in the relevant statute, and CDC’s reasoning on their failure to allow for public comment.
Yes—I work for a federal agency and before any edict can be imposed on the public in my agency three things need to happen: 1) Congress needs to pass a law, then 2) regulations need to be written, and 3) before those regs are implemented, a period of “negotiated rulemaking” needs to occur during which the public and stakeholders can provide feedback. (I’ve attended these “neg reg” sessions.) Then finally—after months—the regulations are finalized and published in the Federal Register.
Skipping the third step violates the Administrative Procedures Act (and skipping the first step violates everything). This is what the federal judge concluded and she seems correct to me.
None of this happened with the CDC and masking.
Biden admin is thinking of taking it to court to,over rule the judge- but with midterms coming, let’s see if they are thst numb or not
....this whole idea of Sleepy Joe’s minions trying to get yet another judge to overturn Judge Mizelle’s ruling is insane...can you imagine the riots that would result at airports, trains stations, bus stations, AMTRAK locations, etc. if this stooooopid mask mandate re-appeared...??!! this nation is not being lead by serious people....
Yep. They are betting on the idea that people are sheep
Exactly so. Especially when the penalty directly impacts violators with substantial civil and/or criminal penalty. I would argue that such deprives those penalized of their due process rights.
I worked for a municipality I had to often tell co-workers that we did not just get to pull stuff out of our butts and “to go by the written.”
If the mask-lovers want to impose their little fetish on everybody, let them start up their own airline where everybody has to strap a piece of dirty laundry (which is what it becomes after about 20 minutes) to their faces.
They can call it “Karen (Restricted) Airways” or something.
The rest of us can fly while breathing freely.
Thank you! I have been looking for a link to the opinion itself for a couple of days!
We FRiends here at Free Republic aim to please!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.